Apr 18, 2014; Pittsburgh, PA, USA; Milwaukee Brewers center fielder Carlos Gomez (center) is greeted in the dugout after hitting a solo home run against the Pittsburgh Pirates during the fifth inning at PNC Park. Mandatory Credit: Charles LeClaire-USA TODAY Sports

Is Carlos Gomez really to blame?

The brawl that took place yesterday between the Milwaukee Brewers and Pittsburgh Pirates may have been one of the most intense between the two teams, and it’s still just April. Two players were ejected in the scuffle, the Brewers’ Carlos Gomez and the Pirates’ Travis Snider. You can watch it here:

Given how the fight broke out, is Gomez really in the wrong here?

I would have to say yes and no. Yes because the whole “bat-flipping” and “admiration” doesn’t go unnoticed, just ask the Atlanta Braves and their no-fun mentality with both Gomez and Miami Marlins’ ace Jose Fernandez. Sure, Gomez thought he had a home run and admired it a little, but what guy doesn’t? Of course, we know now that long-ball ended up being a triple, which fueled the fire for this all out brawl.

And people think baseball is boring.

Gomez got into it last year with Paul Maholm and Brian McCann, but there’s history here. Maholm had a record of plunking Gomez in the past, so when Gomez finally hits a homer off of him, it’s a controversy. Let’s face it, some pitchers are cry babies. Oh boo hoo, someone hit a home run or an extra base hit off of you. Big deal. Yeah, maybe Gomez was admiring his hits for a little too long, but that’s what happens Gerrit Cole when you put a meatball right down the middle of the plate. Same for you Maholm.

I’m not saying I defend home-run, or in this case a triple, admiration, but for teams like the Braves and the Pirates to literally start brawls about it is ridiculous and highly unprofessional. What, is Gomez supposed to be sorry for hitting a ball to deep center off of Cole? Of course not. Gomez even said himself he apologizes for nothing, which he shouldn’t have to. He did his job, plain and simple. Cole overreacted which obviously angered Gomez and then the rest is history.

The one thing I will say about Gomez is he does need to watch his temper. Easily he could just brush off what people say to him, particularly Maholm, McCann, and Cole, but instead he acts on rage. That’s where I do fault Gomez, but at the same time, it is his passion for the game that drives him. Every player has it, but shows it in different ways. Gomez just needs to work on controlling his anger before more bench clearing brawls break out.

So for those people calling Gomez a “punk” or a “thug”, please. He’s a baseball player that does his job, and fairly well at that. So no, I don’t think Gomez is to blame fully. Yes, the watching the ball is partially on him, but the rest is a simple overreaction on Pittsburgh. It’s ridiculous to think Gomez will actually be suspended games because of this. Though, it was nice to see Martin Maldonado land a nice right hook on Snider. That’s always fun.

Next Brewers Game View full schedule »
Saturday, Aug 3030 Aug6:05at San Francisco GiantsBuy Tickets

Tags: Carlos Gomez Milwaukee Brewers

  • Jackjohn Loehr

    I agree. Gomez admiring his homerun err triple, wasn’t wrong, if he was running the whole time it would have been an inside the park homerun. But reacting to Cole was what he did wrong. He should have just stood on 3rd and told Cole he was lucky that he didn’t score. Other teams know that you can get in Gomez’s head by talking trash, and he will react. Carlos needs to know when to react and when to brush it off.

    • Benjamin Orr

      Yep, if that’s all teams have to do to him, it’s going to be a long season. Hopefully he’ll be able to control his temper a bit, so we don’t have these scenarios happen.

  • Sean O’Connell

    Yeah, not to mention the fact that he threw the first punch. The guy is a hot head and if he had stood on 3rd base catching his breath, instead of being insulted by the fact the felt he was being “dissed” by Cole, he wouldnt be facing a 10 game suspesion, nor the scorn of the majority of the baseball world.

    • Justin Schultz

      10 games? He might get three at most.

      • Benjamin Orr

        Yeah, I think a 10 game suspension would be a little overkill. It was fine for Ian Kennedy since he’s a pitcher and missed two starts at most. 10 games for an everyday guy is a significant chunk.

  • http://brewtalk.weebly.com/ Novak

    Yes, Gomez’s antics were over the top and had as much to do with causing the brawl as anyone, but I’d blame the brawl largely on Travis Snider. If you go to the 3:00 minute mark in the video, you see a pretty much defused situation with the umps holding Gomez back. Press play and you’ll see Snider right behind that ump – strutting towards Gomez and saying something to him. Only then did Gomez side step the ump and actually start swinging. Whatever Snider said set off Gomez.

    I also get a kick out of Russel Martin’s hypocrisy complaining about Maldonado’s cheap shot punch on Snider. This is the same guy that can be seen grabbing and pushing Gomez and, later, as Gomez gets knocked to the ground, Martin starts going after him again. Gomez is just lucky Ed Sedar immediately tackled Martin from behind before he could get his own shot in on Gomez.