Milwaukee Brewers: Should They Trade Ryan Braun Over The Winter?

1 of 6

Sep 29, 2015; San Diego, CA, USA; Milwaukee Brewers right fielder Ryan Braun (8) watches the game from the dugout during the ninth inning against the San Diego Padres at Petco Park. Mandatory Credit: Jake Roth-USA TODAY Sports /

For some years, Ryan Braun has been loved and hated by fans of the Milwaukee Brewers. For those that are kids still growing up, they can’t help but be pleased with his accomplishments, But should the team trade Braun?

Braun’s accolades include an NL MVP award, six All-Star Selections, 5 Silver Sluggers, and a Rookie of the Year Award. Additionally, for the Milwaukee Brewers, Braun also hits home runs, has a Major League career batting average over .300 and a career average with Runners in Scoring Position of .315.

For the adult Brewer fans, it is hard for them to ignore the suspension Braun had for PED use. In addition to the PED suspension, it has been well documented that Braun has had nagging injuries such as an oblique/intercostal problem, back issues, and a unique thumb injury that requires him to get a maintenance procedure done every few months.

At the time of this writing, he has missed at least an average of 30 games each year in his big league career, which is a pretty good chunk of the season. Combine the injury history Braun has had along with his past PED problems and his sizable contract, and many adult fans are not exactly thrilled that the Brewers are “stuck with him.”

How long will Ryan Braun Still Be Wearing This Helmet?Mandatory Credit: Kim Klement-USA TODAY Sports /

Ryan Braun is aware of the fact that the rebuilding Brewers could part ways with him.

On Sunday, September 25th, the Brewers played their last home game of the season for 2016. As Braun came up to bat in the 8th inning, fans cheered pretty loudly for Braun because they realized that this might, in fact, be the last time he comes to bat at Miller Park as a Milwaukee Brewer.

Braun even admitted that the chances of him being traded are higher than they have ever been in his career.

In an interview and report by Adam McCalvy of MLB.com, Braun talks about his time with the Brewers.

“I think that people here, at least most of them, recognize there is at least a chance that today is my last home game as a Brewer,” Braun said in the wake of a 4-2 loss to the Reds. “I don’t think there is a great chance, but certainly a higher chance than at any point in the 10 years that I’ve spent here.”

Apr 4, 2015; Phoenix, AZ, USA; Milwaukee Brewers right fielder Ryan Braun (8) waits on deck against the Cleveland Indians at Maryvale Baseball Park. Mandatory Credit: Joe Camporeale-USA TODAY Sports /

A small market team like the Brewers needs to consider all avenues for improving the club. Does trading Ryan Braun make sense?

As we look at the current state of the Milwaukee Brewers franchise and the rest of Braun’s contract, the question is: Does it even make sense to trade him? After looking at the facts, one could make the point that it seems too little too late to deal the guy.

Whether you like him or not, Braun has put up some pretty noticeable overall numbers each season.

He has been a Brewer a long time, and the club made a decision to make him the “Franchise Player” so it may seem like that it does not make sense to trade him NOW after a good portion of his career is already over.

There are those that say even a REBUILDING club needs SOME SORT of stability or something that is proven and works. Whether you like him or not, Braun has put up some pretty noticeable overall numbers each season.

The question that lurks is: Where is the current Brewers lineup going to get their offense from if Braun is gone? Would an offseason free agent signing put up an average over .300 with 30 homers? Not likely. Look at how well the Brewers free agent signings have done. Jeffrey Hammonds anyone?

Domingo Santana has the potential to do great things in the Major Leagues, but he CANNOT be expected to put up Braun numbers!!Mandatory Credit: Jeff Hanisch-USA TODAY Sports /

Who do you expect to replace Ryan Braun’s numbers with the Brewers? Who steps up?

Do you as a fan think that an outfielder currently in the Brewers system would STEP RIGHT IN just like that to fill Braun’s void from Opening Day 2017 on and put up a .300 average and 30 home runs? No Chance! Look, even a REBUILDING TEAM has to have SOME sort of stability.

When I ask where the Brewers will get their offense from, I mean it when I emphasize that I cannot say it enough! The Brewers have already dealt some nice offensive players such as Gerardo Parra, Carlos Gomez, and Jonathan Lucroy among others.

I now feel that Braun needs to be the one that at least helps ‘Steer the ship in the right direction.’

The point is, even a rebuilding team has to understand that they have to put SOME sort of lineup out there. Is Hernan Perez going to bat over .300 and drive in over 90 runs? Heck no.

Do you really think Jonathan Villar will do it, or anyone else on this team will?

When the team puts out a nine-man line up each day for the whole season, and nobody has an average over .260, it is not only depressing; it is pathetic.

How does a team ADVANCE to being a playoff contender without at least SOMETHING that is proven? As much as I did not like having Braun on the team as a “Franchise Player” for several years because I was a Prince Fielder fan, I now feel that Braun needs to be the one that at least helps ‘Steer the ship in the right direction.’

Even the NL Central last-place Cincinnati Reds still have proven players Brandon Phillips and Joey Votto after trading away Jay Bruce and Todd Frazier.

As Ryan Braun gets ready for an at bat before a game, you have to wonder if he is thinking about his contract and future….Mandatory Credit: Eric Hartline-USA TODAY Sports /

Ultimately, the Brewers made a pact. Why pay money to another team to have Braun play for them, just so we can HOPE we get another player who is cheaper?

Braun is owed 72 Million Dollars by the Brewers between the start of the 2017 season and the end of the 2020 season. In 2021, Braun has a mutual option worth $15 million plus performance incentives.

I believe by that point the Brewers would decline to bring him back. It seems reasonable that Braun would probably hang it up and call it a career after the team exercises their part in the option decision.

Is it too late for this type of Ryan Braun trade talk? Are we rearranging deck chairs on the Titanic? Read on about how a rebuilding team should have just have ONE PIECE of stability and keep Braun for life.

Trading Braun now means that you as a team gave up on a long term contract even though you agreed to it with Braun in the beginning. Braun even made some comments in a recent postgame interview that when a player signs a long-term contract, he has to realistically expect that the team will not be in first place all of the time.

More from Reviewing the Brew

While the Brewers are working on rebuilding, does it make sense to pay a team like the Dodgers a portion of Braun’s contract just to get something back that you KNOW will not stack up?

Again I have to say it… WHO STEPS UP AND PLAYS for the Brewers if Braun gets traded? Do you expect Lewis Brinson or Domingo Santana to hit 30 home runs and bat .300 every season? They could get there with some seasoning, but certainly not right away and certainly not on a consistent basis.

We all know Hernan Perez and Martin Maldonado won’t be the guys to do it. Villar is probably the only Brewer currently on the roster who has a shot at eventually making 30 and .300.

Next: 2011 to 2016 Roster Comparison - 2nd Base Edition

I do not think the Brewers realize that trading Braun could result in a hole in the offense BIG ENOUGH to result in the team taking a significant hit in the win and loss column. I never thought I would say it, but yes, keep Braun a Brewer for life.

Home / Brewers News