Milwaukee Brewers: Ranking the top 20 prospects

Last week, MLB Pipeline released the updated top 100 prospect list. They also released an updated top 30 prospect list for the Milwaukee Brewers.

There were quite a few changes to the Milwaukee Brewers prospect list. Some players either under performed, or were traded and dropped from the list. Others have excelled to improve their standing. What follows is the official Reviewing the Brew top 20 prospects. MLB rankings are in parentheses.

20- Josh Pennington RHP (22)

Pennington was acquired as part of the Tyler Thornburg trade this past off-season with the Boston Red Sox. He has had a few different arm injuries in his career. When the Red Sox drafted him, 24th overall in 2014 out of high school, they did so knowing he needed Tommy John surgery.

According to his MLB scouting report, Pennington throws a plus-plus fastball. Unfortunately, he hasn’t quite figured out how to throw strikes consistently. He throws an above average curveball, but hasn’t figured out how to throw a consistent change-up.

His fastball alone makes him an intriguing prospect. Most projections see him as a reliever in the big leagues. Either way, don’t expect to see him as a Milwaukee Brewer anytime soon.

19- Jacob Nottingham C (19)

Nottingham is a project at catcher. He will need to stay at the position to make it to the major leagues. He has struggled with the bat since joining the Brewers organization.

Never thought of as a defensive catcher, Nottingham has done his best to change that this season. He allowed a staggering 21 passed balls a year ago. This season, he has cut that number down to seven.

If he continues to improve defensively, Nottingham could prove to be a very useful player in the big leagues. At worst, he should be adequate enough defensively to be a backup. With his size, he can also help out at first base.

18- K.J. Harrison C (17)

Drafted in the third round of this years draft, K.J. Harrison is another project at catcher. This ranking feels a little bit too high, but Harrison can swing the bat. The Milwaukee Brewers feel confident he can catch. In college, he never had the opportunity to catch on a regular basis. His bat still kept him in the lineup daily.

At 6-feet tall and a shade over 200 pounds, Harrison has the size for the position. His MLB scouting report grades him as above average for his hit skill. His power, arm, and defense all grade as average. He has all the tools to be successful in the  Major Leagues. The question with him is at what position?

First base would definitely be an option for Harrison. It’s hard to project catchers, but if the Brewers believe he can play the position, then he probably can. You can never have too many catchers in the system. Manny Piña is currently entrenched at the position in the majors. There is plenty of time for Harrison to put it all together.

17- Jake Gatewood 1B (18)

Gatewood was a high-risk, high-reward prospect when the Milwaukee Brewers selected him in the 2014 draft. Drafted as a shortstop, Gatewood has shifted over to first base for a clearer path to the majors.

It has taken him some time, but Gatewood seems to be settling in at the plate. This season, playing for the Carolina Mud Cats, he has hit 11 home runs in 395 at bats. Unfortunately, the 122 strikeouts to this point really stand out.

Gatewood is helped at the plate with his plus bat speed. This season, he has started wearing contact lenses, and that seems to have helped his plate discipline. He has walked 42 times this season, more than doubling his total from a year ago.

Hitting .268 with a .341 on base percentage, Gatewood looks like he’s only beginning to find himself as a baseball player. Having committed 14 errors at first base, he shows he has a long way to go before he reaches The Show.

16- Trey Supak RHP (16)

Supak throws an above average curveball and fastball. He also throws an average change-up, with average control. He has the makings of a successful Major League pitcher.

His three average or better pitches will help him as he progresses. He throws his fastball in the low 90’s with decent control. His curveball will help keep hitters off-balance. Only 21 years old, there is a lot of work to be done.

With his 6’5″ frame, Supak could be able to become an innings eater in the middle of the Milwaukee Brewers rotation. This season pitching for the Carolina Mud Cats, he has struggled with a 4.78 ERA through nine starts.

For his career, he has shown solid ability to limit walks. This season, he has allowed 21 walks with 50 strikeouts, in 58 1/3 innings for Carolina. In 99 1/3 innings, with the Wisconsin Timber Rattlers earlier this year, Supak had only 31 walks while striking out 103. He has shown good command of the strike zone already, and this attribute should only improve with time.

15- Monte Harrison OF (14)

Harrison has struggled to stay on the field early in his career in the Milwaukee Brewers system. A second round draft pick in 2014, this season is his healthiest as a professional.

His numbers don’t exactly jump off the page. Through two levels of the Minor Leagues, in 91 games, his batting line is .257/.347/.465. Those 91 games are already the most he has played in a single season.

With 18 stolen bases in 21 attempts this season, he shows good ability on the basepaths. That speed also translates well to the outfield. His scouting report grades him out as a plus runner, and it has shown.

He also received an above average grade for his fielding. Harrison also has a cannon for an arm. He will be able to play anywhere in the outfield. The question with him, is whether he will hit enough to reach the Major Leagues.

With his injury setbacks, Harrison is a little behind where he should be. The good thing for him, the Milwaukee Brewers won’t have a need for an outfielder any time soon. He will have plenty of time to refine his approach at the plate. In time, he will contribute to a Major League roster.

12- Freddy Peralta RHP (11)

Peralta throws his fastball in the low to mid 90’s. According to his MLB scouting report, his slider and change-up are already major league ready. He has already flashed strikeout stuff in the minors, as his command improves he will only get better.

In 91 2/3 innings, over two levels of the Minor Leagues, Peralta has 128 strikeouts and only 46 walks this season. That’s good for a 2.78 K/BB ratio. He has only allowed 19 home runs over 331 innings over his five seasons in the Minors.

Playing for the Biloxi Shuckers, he has continued to show an ability to command all three of his pitches. He strikes out a ton of batters when he’s right. He’s destined to fill a meaningful role in the middle of a Major League rotation, and he could arrive as early as next season. However, 2019 would be a better bet.

11- Keston Hiura 2B (5)

By this time next season, Hiura could easily be the Milwaukee Brewers number one prospect. However, before that can happen, he will have to show that he can play the field defensively.

Without question Hiura can hit. In 58 at bats so far with the Wisconsin Timber Rattlers this season, Hiura has a .368/.379/.526 batting line. He is tearing the cover off of the ball.

Hiura opted not to have surgery on his injured elbow. To this point, he has played zero innings in the field this season, strictly at designated hitter. Listed as a second baseman, he may well end up in left field when it’s all said and done.

There is little doubt Hiura will have a productive Major League career. He has shown a great feel for hitting at every level he has played. He may be more of a trade chip prospect for the Milwaukee Brewers. However, if he can prove adequate defensively he develop into a force in the middle of the Brewers lineup within a few years.

Next: Whatever Happened To Tyrone Taylor?

There are some really good prospects in the system right now. However, this is only a glimpse of the future for the Milwaukee Brewers. Stay tuned for top ten.