Skip to main content

3 dark horse trade candidates Brewers could move following 2026 World Series run

Milwaukee has been known to move a surprise player or two during the offseason.
ByTyler Koerth
Oct 14, 2026; Los Angeles, California, USA;  Milwaukee Brewers shortstop Joey Ortiz (3) reacts to striking out against the Los Angeles Dodgers during the second inning in game three of the NLCS for the 2026 MLB Playoffs at Uniqlo Field at Dodger Stadium.  Mandatory Credit: Kirby Lee-Imagn Images
Oct 14, 2026; Los Angeles, California, USA; Milwaukee Brewers shortstop Joey Ortiz (3) reacts to striking out against the Los Angeles Dodgers during the second inning in game three of the NLCS for the 2026 MLB Playoffs at Uniqlo Field at Dodger Stadium. Mandatory Credit: Kirby Lee-Imagn Images | IMAGN IMAGES via Reuters Connect

Since capturing the franchise's first World Series title less than one month ago, the Milwaukee Brewers' offseason has moved at a rapid pace, in large part due to the anticipated December 1 work stoppage.

With a week and a half until the expected lockout, the Brewers' roster has already undergone several notable changes, headlined by the departure of Jake Bauers, who was the first major free agent to sign elsewhere after playing a vital role in Milwaukee's championship run. Dustin May has also landed with the Chicago White Sox, while Brandon Woodruff, JoJo Romero, and Gary Sánchez remain among the Brewers' notable free agents.

Meanwhile, Milwaukee added six Rule 5 Draft-eligible prospects to their 40-man roster: 1B/3B Luke Adams, INF/OF Dylan O'Rae, INF/OF Jett Williams, C Matthew Wood, LHP Tate Kuehner, and RHP Cameron Wagoner. Additionally, Matt Arnold has already swung a trade, acquiring reliever Ryan Walker in exchange for two prospects. With plenty of moving pieces and a potentially shortened window to conduct business, it may not be too much longer before another deal is executed, this time with more impactful players being involved. Here, we take a look at three possible surprise trade candidates.

3 under-the-radar trade candidates Brewers' front office could surprise fanbase by moving this offseason

1. OF Garrett Mitchell

2026 couldn't have gone much better for Garrett Mitchell. He didn't just help the Brewers capture their first World Series title; he played a pivotal role in getting them to the Fall Classic. Mitchell delivered a momentum-swinging, home-run-robbing catch to help shut down the San Diego Padres' comeback hopes in the NLDS before launching home runs in back-to-back games against the Los Angeles Dodgers in the NLCS.

Furthermore, after several injury-plagued seasons, Mitchell managed to avoid the injured list entirely in 2026. He also posted a 116 wRC+ while serving as Milwaukee's primary center fielder, pairing above-average offensive production with outstanding defense. According to Baseball Savant, Mitchell recorded seven Outs Above Average, placing him in the top seventh percentile among major-league defenders.

So why even consider trading him now? For starters, Mitchell's trade value may never be higher. He's coming off the best and healthiest season of his career, carries a modest $2.7 million arbitration projection, and still has three additional seasons of team control. Beyond that appeal, Milwaukee also has intriguing options waiting in the wings. Luis Lara is ready for an extended opportunity at the big-league level, while the Brewers' No. 5 overall prospect, Josh Adamczewski, is knocking on the door after recording his third consecutive minor-league season with a batting average above .300 and an OPS north of .900. Trading Mitchell certainly wouldn't be a popular decision among Brewers fans, but given his current value and the organization's outfield depth, he represents one of Milwaukee's more appealing trade assets.

2. INF Joey Ortiz

An offseason ago, the Brewers' front office sold high on strong seasons from both Isaac Collins and Caleb Durbin. Realizing that both players may have out-performed their expected production, the Brewers capitalized by including both in offseason trades -- Collins went to the Kansas City Royals for Ángel Zerpa and Durbin landed with the Boston Red Sox in a six-player deal that sent David Hamilton, Shane Drohan, and Kyle Harrison to Milwaukee. If the Brewers were to continue this trend of selling high on their players who may regress in future seasons, Joey Ortiz is a strong candidate to be moved.

After getting off to a very slow start in 2026, Ortiz bounced back with a ridiculously strong second half of the season. In fact, Ortiz's .323 batting average from July 1 to the end of the season ranked fifth in the entire National League. The fourth-year infielder, who took over as close to the everyday third baseman, was a key part of the Brewers' record-breaking season. And yet, there's reason to believe Ortiz is due for regression in 2027 -- his expected stats significantly trailed his actual production in 2026 -- and therefore a player who could be moved this offseason.

The Brewers have also been known to move players for whom they have replacements and with Jesús Made knocking on the door of the big leagues, trading one of Ortiz or Hamilton this offseason if the right deal presents itself, certainly holds some merit. With the Royals' recent Maikel Garcia trade serving as an example, a strong defender with average offensive production can yield an exciting return. Perhaps the Brewers can find one by selling other teams on Ortiz's strong second half.

3. 1B/DH Andrew Vaughn

While "King Vaughn" was arguably the Brewers' saving grace during the 2025 season, he conceded significant playing time to Jake Bauers in 2026. Vaughn still made 104 appearances, but recorded just 331 plate appearances, the lowest total of his career. Although he remained productive in a more limited role, Milwaukee now faces an interesting decision. With just one year of team control remaining and a qualifying offer seemingly unlikely without a significant breakout in 2027, why not explore his trade market now?

Beyond that, Milwaukee has already begun integrating the next wave of its youth movement, with shortstop Cooper Pratt and outfielder Luis Lara signing long-term extensions last year. After adding six prospects to the 40-man roster last week to protect them from the Rule 5 Draft, including right-handed hitting corner infielder Luke Adams, why not continue that youth trend at first base?

Carrying two right-handed options at first base in Adams and Vaughn wouldn't be particularly unusual, but trading Vaughn could create another valuable roster spot for an emerging prospect -- and free up $8.5 million in payroll space according to MLB Trade Rumors' projections. Players such as Blake Burke or Andrew Fisher, both of whom can man the cold corner but hit from the left side, could offer a different look and provide Milwaukee with more lineup flexibility. Given the organization's emphasis on developing its next generation of talent, moving Vaughn now could make sense from both a roster-construction and long-term planning standpoint.

Add us as a preferred source on Google