A Silver Slugger quirk could give Brewers' breakout star Jake Bauers a chance at elusive award

In the middle of a race for the best record in the league, the Milwaukee Brewers don't have much time to focus on various awards races. Luckily, we do, and I really want to take a look at Jake Bauers' case for the Silver Slugger Award this year.

By this point, everyone knows how good and clutch he's been at the plate in 2026. He's posting career highs in basically every offensive category, batting .272/.382/.501 (144 wRC+) with 23 homers, 75 RBIs, and nine steals for good measure. He belongs in the Silver Slugger conversation at first base on those merits alone, but what if I told you he has another path toward winning?

According to Louisville Slugger, who gives out the Silver Slugger Awards, a player must have "a minimum of 100 games with at least 20 games played at two or more positions," in order to qualify for the Silver Slugger Award at the utility position. Bauers, who has appeared in 96 games at first base and 43 games in the outfield (split between left and right), certainly qualifies as a utility player under those conditions.

Thanks to his defensive versatility and an incredible breakout season at the plate, Bauers is practically guaranteed to at least finish as a finalist in Silver Slugger voting this year.

Jake Bauers could end up winning the NL Silver Slugger Award as a utility player if he loses 1B race to Braves' Matt Olson

FanGraphs unfortunately doesn't offer an option to sort "utility players," but just looking at Bauers' ranks among his first base contemporaries should tell you all you need to know about his Silver Slugger candidacy.

Among qualified National League first basemen, he ranks first in wRC+ and OPS (.884); second in on-base percentage (.382) and slugging percentage (.501); and fourth in fWAR (2.9). Take his defense out of the equation (i.e., factor in only his baserunning and contributions at the plate), and FanGraphs considers Bauers the most valuable player at the position in the Senior Circuit this year. That said, it will be hard for voters to ignore the impressive season that Atlanta Braves' first baseman Matt Olson is putting together. Olson already has 36 homers and 32 doubles on the season.

Bauers might get dinged by old-school voters for his relative lack of counting stats -- he ranks fifth at the position in both homers and RBIs, and he has the second-biggest strikeout rate among the qualified bunch -- but there's no way to deny how good he's been on an overall basis.

However, though we can't individually compare him to other utility players, a quick glance at Bauers' rankings among all NL players gives a pretty clear indication that he could certainly take home the award at that position if the voters are willing to consider him there. He ranks fourth in the NL in wRC+ and OPS among those qualified for the leaderboards, and the only players in his vicinity that could challenge him at the utility spot are Bryce Harper and Sal Stewart. However, Harper still doesn't have the starts in the outfield to qualify as a utility player, and Bauers bests Stewart in batting average, on-base percentage, and slugging percentage even if his counting stats trail Stewart's in most categories.

Overall, regardless of what position his name appears under, Bauers has an excellent case to at least be a Silver Slugger finalist for the first time in his career this year. Though many may not view him as a utility player, Bauers' sneaky defensive versatility could end up earning him the elusive award.

Add us as a preferred source on Google

Follow