Brewers' dominant NLCS victory over Dodgers vindicates Matt Arnold’s trade deadline strategy

The reason why you go out and acquire someone like Tarik Skubal at the trade deadline is because of the influence he, as an individual, can have over a postseason series. You'd certainly have to feel very good about your chances to win a five- or seven-game series in which the reigning back-to-back AL Cy Young Award winner makes two starts. Or, at least that was the Los Angeles Dodgers' reasoning for going all-in on him over the summer.

The Milwaukee Brewers, of course, didn't let Skubal get to that second start. They had to take down a quartet of aces to do it, but by sweeping the Los Angeles Dodgers in the NLCS, they've more than vindicated the front office's trade deadline strategy of pursuing many valuable role players rather than one gigantic north star.

Brewers' patient, sustainable philosophy finally paid off against all-in Dodgers

Even with Dustin May failing to pan out in the Brewers' renowned pitching lab, they've gotten key contributions from JoJo Romero and Antonio Senzatela out of the bullpen this October. The former pitched three tremendous innings against the Dodgers in the NLCS, allowing just one hit while recording a negative FIP (-0.23). The latter performed similarly in the NLDS, making two key appearances against the Padres.

Again, there were failures from the deadline. May wasn't great down the stretch (5.65 ERA) and he's become nearly impossible to trust in the postseason (6.43 ERA); Bo Naylor hasn't made the postseason rosters (but remains a key piece of the future) while Codi Heuer got dumped immediately; even Lance McCullers lasted less than two weeks before being DFA'd. To say that Matt Arnold had a flawless performance on the trade market would be inaccurate.

But, by adhering to organizational philosophy, he gave the Brewers what they needed most: margin for error. The bullpen got a jolt from the newcomers, the offense found its groove late in the season thanks to continuity, and the rotation didn't miss a beat even without a Skubal-sized boost.

And by not trading for Skubal, Arnold has done more than just position this franchise to win now. Holding onto Logan Henderson and Luis Peña -- two of the Tigers' biggest asks at the deadline -- not only looks prescient right now in the aftermath of the NLCS, but should pay massive dividends over the next six or seven years as well.

Arnold's strategy is really just a continuation of the same magic trick the Brewers have been pulling off year after year for some time now. There are few, if any, other organizations that could trade Corbin Burnes, Freddy Peralta, Josh Hader, and Devin Williams over a five-year stretch and get better in that same window. It's never been about any one year for Milwaukee -- going "all-in" flies in the face of what they've been building since the mid-2010s.

With Skubal and the Dodgers now out of the way, it is all about 2026 and the chance for that elusive title. But it's important to remember that the Brewers didn't sell out to get here; what they've built is something sustainable.

Add us as a preferred source on Google

Follow