Brewers' four-player trade with Guardians kicks off pivotal deadline on a surprising note

One year ago, nobody was expecting the Milwaukee Brewers to trade for a catcher at the trade deadline, so when Matt Arnold and company started their trade season off by acquiring catcher Danny Jansen from the Tampa Bay Rays, many fans were left rather surprised. A similar story is unfolding this year, as the Brewers weren't necessarily in the market for a backstop, but their front office has just kicked off the trade deadline by acquiring one from the Cleveland Guardians.

As reported by Zack Meisel of The Athletic, the Brewers have traded outfielder Blake Perkins and reliever Craig Yoho to the Cleveland Guardians for catcher Bo Naylor and reliever Codi Heuer.

It's certainly not the trade most Brewers fans were expecting their front office to make to start the trade frenzy, but it's one that seemingly lays the base for more moves over the next three days. With Naylor, the Brewers will be adding a fourth catcher to their 40-man roster, and one who is under team control through the 2030 season, suggesting that either Gary Sánchez or top prospect Jeferson Quero could be on the move before Monday's deadline.

Brewers acquire Bo Naylor and Codi Heuer from Guardians for Blake Perkins and Craig Yoho in first deadline trade

Naylor is certainly an interesting addition for the Brewers. The 26-year-old left-handed hitting catcher, brother of Seattle Mariners slugger Josh Naylor, broke into the league with a strong 67 games back in 2023, during which he crushed 11 homers and posted a 121 OPS+. However, in the years since, Naylor has seen his numbers plummet, so much so that the once-everyday catcher for the Guardians has spent the last two months in Triple-A. There's certainly some pop in his bat, as Naylor crushed double-digit homers in each season from 2023-2025, and he doesn't chase much at the plate -- something the Brewers love -- but Milwaukee will have to unlock his former potential before he becomes a big-league regular once more.

Heuer, meanwhile, is a similar story, but on the pitching side of things. The 30-year-old right-hander broke into the league with the Chicago White Sox back in 2020 and posted a strong 1.52 ERA in 23.2 innings pitched. However, in the time since, he's bounced around the league, and struggled to find his footing in a big-league 'pen. In just 9.2 innings this year, Heuer has a 4.66 ERA and a 1.76 WHIP.

In the trade, the Brewers parted ways with two players, Perkins and Yoho, who were on the edge of their major league roster. Perkins was stuck behind a line of outfielders that now includes rookie Luis Lara and the soon-to-be returning Brandon Lockridge, who has been out with an injury since early May. There was no path to playing time for Perkins in Milwaukee this year, and seemingly now way for him to carve out a role in future seasons either. He should have a clearer path to playing time in Cleveland.

Yoho, meanwhile, certainly has potential, with one of the most unique pitches in the sport, his changeup, leading to dominance in the minor leagues. However, the 26-year-old right-hander has struggled mightily with command at the major league level, and it appears the Brewers' patience with their young, controllable reliever has run its course. Even still, it's not difficult to envision Yoho becoming a very good big-league reliever at some point in his career, especially after joining the Guardians who also excel in pitching development.

As previously mentioned, the four-player swap seems to suggest at least two moves are still on the horizon for the Brew Crew. Naylor's addition theoretically makes Sánchez available on what is a strong market for teams selling catchers. It's possible the Brewers use their veteran backstop to improve their major league roster elsewhere, or throw Quero into a blockbuster deal before Monday's deadline. Additionally, with both Naylor and Heuer heading to Triple-A to begin their careers in the Brewers organization, the move trims Milwaukee's major-league roster and opens the door for several impactful additions in the coming days.

Add us as a preferred source on Google

Follow