Brewers make shocking roster decision ahead of Opening Day as pitching woes mount

As all 30 MLB teams finalize their rosters ahead of Opening Day, the Milwaukee Brewers are making some unexpected moves that are a cause for concern among fans. While the team is looking to secure a third consecutive NL Central title, the way they plan to open the season suggests they’ll be hobbling out of the gate rather than storming through it.

As reported by Adam McCalvy of MLB.com, one of the most notable developments is the handling of recently acquired starting pitcher José Quintana. Unsurprisingly, the Brewers have opted to send the veteran left-hander to the minors to continue his build-up. Given his late signing — Quintana needs a little more time before assuming a regular spot in the rotation. What’s more concerning, however, is what this move really means: Milwaukee will be rolling out just three true starting pitchers to open the season.

Quintana’s debut delayed and Chad Patrick's unexpected call-up

Quintana is tentatively aiming for a mid-April return, but if the Brewers' stopgap solutions falter, that timeline could feel like an eternity.

The plan is to rely on a patchwork approach to cover innings. Tyler Alexander, Chad Patrick, Elvin Rodríguez, and Connor Thomas are all expected to fill bulk-innings roles, either as spot starters or multi-inning bullpen arms. The strategy is clear — survive the first couple of weeks with placeholders — a risky gamble, especially in a competitive division.

Adding to the intrigue is the inclusion of Chad Patrick on the Opening Day roster, just weeks after he had been optioned to minor league camp. His sudden return underscores the Brewers' lack of rotation depth and their willingness to burn a minor league option just to have a serviceable innings-eater on hand. 

Bauers' strong spring secures his roster spot

On the position player side, the Brewers opted for familiarity, keeping Jake Bauers on the roster while passing on highly touted prospect Tyler Black. Many fans had hoped to see Black step into an infield role as a backup for Rhys Hoskins or even as an option at third base. However, a lackluster spring from Black combined with a stronger showing from Bauers likely influenced the Brewers’ decision to stick with the veteran slugger. While Bauers' raw power is undeniable, his strikeout-heavy profile makes him a volatile presence.

The Brewers also included outfielder Isaac Collins, a lesser-known depth option who provides versatility and defensive flexibility. While his role isn’t expected to be significant out of the gate, he could be a valuable asset if injuries or underperformance create opportunities for playing time.

With a short-handed rotation and an offense that still has question marks, how Milwaukee navigates these early challenges could shape their entire season. If they weather this storm, it’s possible they’ll come out okay. But if they find themselves having to play catch-up in this division, trouble could be on the horizon.

More Brewers News from Reviewing the Brew