Brewers must stay clear of this sun-running Mariners trade candidate at 2026 deadline

Thanks to Matt Arnold's disciplined nature, the Milwaukee Brewers have avoided "all-in" moves at the deadline in recent years. Perhaps an exception could be made for Tarik Skubal in the hopes that he gives the team a CC Sabathia-like boost down the stretch, but the enormous prospect haul he'll command is way outside of the Brewers' typical wheelhouse, especially for a rental arm.

Instead, if the Crew are going to go big on a starter this summer, it will likely be someone they can pair with Kyle Harrison and Jacob Misiorowski atop the rotation for the foreseeable future. And, unlike in years past, there actually projects to be quite a few of those types available; all of Reid Detmers, José Soriano, and Joe Ryan have been connected to the Brewers at some point or another in recent weeks.

In the coming days, we may soon be able to add Emerson Hancock to that list. The 27-year-old is in the midst of the best season of his career and isn't even arbitration eligible until 2028 (under team control through 2030). And in their pursuit of offensive upgrades at the trade deadline, the Mariners plan to make him available.

So, why exactly should the Brewers avoid him?

Brewers shouldn't buy high on Emerson Hancock's smoke-and-mirrors season at trade deadline

This is a classic case of a team trying to sell high from a position of strength. The Mariners have perhaps the best pitching pipeline in the league, including a pair of elite prospects (Kade Anderson and Ryan Sloan) who haven't even debuted in the big leagues yet and can afford to part with one of their bright young starters.

To that point, Hancock has had an impressive season on the surface, pitching to a 3.26 ERA over 110.1 innings. Even his 3.75 FIP (fielding independent pitching) is worth admiring, especially in conjunction with a pristine walk rate (6.2%) and a four-seam fastball that is one of the most valuable pitches in baseball (+14 run value). The Brewers love pitchers who have those kinds of outlier offerings, and Hancock has the sinker (+6 run value) and sweeper (36.4% whiff rate) to keep hitters from sitting on his primary pitch.

The problem is simple: that's where the good news comes to an end. Hancock is magically working with a .254 BABIP despite allowing a hard-hit rate of 43.9% (14th percentile), which just screams impending regression. He's also merely average at inducing ground-ball contact and striking batters out, and that might even be overselling his abilities since he ranks in the bottom-third among qualified starters in whiff and chase rate.

The Mariners will try to sell him for a king's ransom because of what he is: a young, cost-controlled starter seemingly on the upswing. That kind of player rarely becomes available, especially not during the middle of a season. But Seattle is also in the playoff hunt, and they'll expect major-league-ready contributors in exchange for Hancock.

The Brewers probably could meet their asking price and gift them the MLB-ready pieces they're looking for, but buying high has never been this front office's M.O. Expect them to turn their attention elsewhere for rotation help before Aug. 3 comes and goes.

Add us as a preferred source on Google

Follow