Skip to main content

Brewers' prospect promotion spree could lead to difficult roster decisions ahead of lockout

Already with a full roster, the Brewers now need to make a subtraction in order to make any offseason additions.
ByOwen Jonas
Oct 2, 2024; Milwaukee, Wisconsin, USA; Milwaukee Brewers general manager Matt Arnold talks to manager Matt Arnold before game two of the Wildcard round for the 2024 MLB Playoffs against the New York Mets at American Family Field. Mandatory Credit: Benny Sieu-Imagn Images
Oct 2, 2024; Milwaukee, Wisconsin, USA; Milwaukee Brewers general manager Matt Arnold talks to manager Matt Arnold before game two of the Wildcard round for the 2024 MLB Playoffs against the New York Mets at American Family Field. Mandatory Credit: Benny Sieu-Imagn Images | USA TODAY Sports via Reuters Connect

Less than two weeks remain before Major League Baseball is expected to enter into a lockout, and plenty needs to happen in those 12 days. Free agents hoping to know their 2027 homes before the league prevents contact with team executives will want to put pen to paper in the coming days, and the many trade rumors around the industry will need to be settled before the negotiating window comes to a close for what could be several months.

The Milwaukee Brewers, fresh off of their first World Series title in franchise history, have the luxury of returning a roster similar to the one that made history in 2026, but are by no means immune to this upcoming two-week offseason sprint. With added revenue from their World Series championship that they may or may not elect to spend on the free agent market and trade candidates to make decisions on, the Brewers, on the heels of their World Series run, are expected to be and have been just as busy as any other team.

From offering Jake Bauers the $23.15 million qualifying offer before watching him sign a four-year, $58 million deal with the Boston Red Sox, to picking up William Contreras' $15.5 million club option after his World Series MVP performance, to trading for San Francisco Giants' reliever Ryan Walker to bolster their bullpen depth, Matt Arnold and the Brewers' front office have been busy through the first three weeks of the offseason.

Continuing that busy start to the offseason was Tuesday night's deadline to add prospects to the 40-man roster and therefore protect them from the Rule 5 Draft, which may or may not happen this year. Typically, the Brewers and teams around the league add two or three prospects to their roster who they believe are at risk of being taken in the Rule 5 Draft, but this year Milwaukee added a whopping six minor leaguers to their 40-man roster: INF Luke Adams, UTL Dylan O'Rae, UTL Jett Williams, C Matthew Wood, LHP Tate Kuehner, and RHP Cameron Wagoner.

It's certainly a justifiable move from the reigning champs. With there still being a possibility that the Rule 5 Draft occurs, why risk losing one of their many talented prospects for nothing, especially when they have the open roster spots? However, the decision does leave them with a full 40-man roster, meaning any further additions the Brewers make this offseason will need to be accompanied by a subtraction.

Brewers' full 40-man roster following Rule 5 Draft protection deadline could lead to tough conversations as lockout looms

Not only do the Brewers have a full 40-man roster despite watching several players from their 2026 squad reach free agency, but they have a very talented and very deep 40-man roster, which means there aren't many obvious candidates to be designated for assignment (DFA) if the front office does want to make an addition or two.

Friday's non-tender deadline could open up a roster spot. Left-handed reliever Ángel Zerpa who won't return until the final weeks of the 2027 season, is certainly a name to watch as the non-tender deadline draws nearer. However, outside of Zerpa, the Brewers don't have any obvious non-tender candidates, meaning at most, Milwaukee will open one 40-man roster spot tomorrow.

A trade of Trevor Megill is certainly still on the table and would effectively open a 40-man roster spot as well, depending on what kind of return the Brewers prioritize. Megill appears to be the most likely Brewers trade candidate to move this offseason, but Milwaukee may need to backfill their bullpen with an external addition or two, meaning more 40-man spots will need to be opened.

Other trades could certainly work to open more 40-man spots for the Brewers, but there's certainly a world where Milwaukee is forced to DFA one or two players this offseason to make room for a free agent addition. Though not obvious DFA candidates, Tyler Black, who is out of minor league options, perhaps Garrett Stallings, if the Brewers don't trust his 2026 performance, and maybe even one of the recently added prospects, are at the bottom of the Brewers' depth chart and could receive the short end of the stick as a result.

The Brewers' organizational depth is admirable, and the fact that they don't take any 40-man roster spot for granted is a large reason why the organization has found so much success over the last decade. However, that depth will inevitably lead to roster logjams, like the one the Brewers currently find themselves in should they want to make an external addition or two before the lockout arrives.

Add us as a preferred source on Google