Last night's Louisville Slugger Silver Slugger Awards show, which aired exclusively on FanSided's own "The Baseball Insiders" podcast and YouTube show, was unsurprisingly kind to the 103-win 2026 Milwaukee Brewers. As announced by Adam Weirnrib and Robert Murry, the hosts of The Baseball Insiders, Jake Bauers and Jackson Chourio won their first Silver Slugger Awards this year, Chourio expectedly, as an outfielder, and Bauers, somewhat unexpectedly, as a utility player.
The reveal of this year's Silver Sluggers continued what has been a strong awards season for the reigning champs. Both Chourio and Brice Turang won Gold Gloves right off the bat, then Brewers skipper Pat Murphy took home his record-breaking third consecutive Manager of the Year Award, and the following day Jacob Misiorowski was named the 2026 NL Cy Young. Now, add a pair of Silver Sluggers to that mix and it's safe to say the Brewers have been properly recognized for their memorable 2026 season.
Awards season has also been kind to the Brewers' current arch rivals, the Chicago Cubs. The Cubs, who picked up 89 wins in 2026, also grabbed two individual Gold Gloves -- one to third baseman Alex Bregman and one to center fielder Pete Crow-Armstrong -- as well as the NL Team Gold Glove Award. Then, Cubs fans watched Crow-Armstrong dethrone Shohei Ohtani in an NL MVP race in which Turang finished as the third finalist.
Last night, the Cubs, like the Brewers, took home two individual Silver Slugger Awards -- one to Bregman at third base and one to Crow-Armstrong in center. Additionally, the Cubs collectively won the Team Silver Slugger honor. So, in addition to both Bregman and Crow-Armstrong adding silver and gold to their trophy cases this year, the Cubs as a team won both the Silver Slugger and Gold Glove Awards. And Chicago still finished 14 games behind the Brewers in the standings. Perhaps the awards are a nice consolation prize for the North Siders after the Brew Crew's World Series title.
Given the Cubs' 2026 record and their recognition in this year's awards season, it's rather apparent that Chicago's pitching staff didn't carry its weight. That's communicated simply by the fact that Chicago, despite having the best defense in baseball, had a team ERA of 4.12 that ranked 14th in MLB. However, given their above-average defensive unit, perhaps FIP (Fielding Independent Pitching) a statistic that captures the value of a pitcher regardless of the defense behind them, is a better evaluator of Chicago's 2026 pitching staff. The Cubs collectively ranked 25th in baseball with a 4.60 FIP in 2026.
Pair that underwhelming performance with the fact that a majority of arms on the Cubs' 2026 pitching staff were free agents at season's end, and Chicago's front office has a daunting task ahead of them this offseason. Said task -- replace and improve the pitching staff -- is made more apparent by the fact that the Cubs were deemed to have the best offense and defense in the National League by the end-of-season awards.
Cubs' Silver Slugger victory doubles down front office's offseason task of re-inventing the pitching staff
As the Brewers enjoy what should be a relatively tame offseason in the wake of their World Series title run, with a majority of key contributors from their record-breaking 2026 season set to return for the 2027 campaign, the Cubs are left with a shell of a pitching staff and a questionable outfield picture following their 89-win season.
Seven multi-inning arms from the Cubs' Wild Card Series roster have hit free agency -- Kevin Gausman, Matthew Boyd, David Peterson, Clay Holmes, Shota Imanaga, and old friends Colin Rea and Aaron Civale. While considering how to close the 14-win gap that exists between them and the World Champions, the Cubs need to also focus on simply covering innings next year. Options exist on the free agent market, but Chicago's need for a large quantity of arms may limit the quality of each individual pitcher they sign. Perhaps the Cubs will turn to the trade market, as they did in August at the deadline, to reconstruct their rotation.
In the meantime, Chicago also lost two talented corner outfielders in Seiya Suzuki and Ian Happ to free agency and needs to consider how to replace them. Should the Cubs elect not to re-sign either bat, but replace them internally and focus their money solely on the pitching staff, Matt Shaw, Justin Dean, Pedro Ramírez, and Kevin Alcántara are all options to man a corner outfield position. That quartet is unlikely to replace the production of Happ and Suzuki, but the Cubs' pitching needs may force them to spend money elsewhere.
It's undoubtedly an impressive feat for the Cubs -- winning both the Team Gold Glove and Team Silver Slugger Award in 2026. However, it speaks to just how uninspiring their pitching staff was in 2026 for the team to only reach 89 wins, and with much of that staff reaching free agency, the Cubs' front office has a clear need to address this offseason. It won't come cheaply, as Dustin May's three-year, $52.5 million deal revealed, but the Cubs are in for a rotation reconstruction this offseason.
