Skip to main content

How Dustin May’s free agency decision impacts Brewers’ offseason rotation plans

Might Milwaukee explore the starting pitcher free agent market in the wake of May's decision?
ByEvan Frederiksen
Oct 27, 2026; St. Petersburg, Florida, USA;  Milwaukee Brewers pitcher Dustin May (21) reacts after pitching against the Tampa Bay Rays during the second inning in game four of the 2026 World Series at Tropicana Field.  Mandatory Credit: Kim Klement Neitzel-Imagn Images
Oct 27, 2026; St. Petersburg, Florida, USA; Milwaukee Brewers pitcher Dustin May (21) reacts after pitching against the Tampa Bay Rays during the second inning in game four of the 2026 World Series at Tropicana Field. Mandatory Credit: Kim Klement Neitzel-Imagn Images | IMAGN IMAGES via Reuters Connect

The Milwaukee Brewers are already facing some important decisions as they begin preparing for the 2027 season. After putting together a phenomenal 2026 campaign and capturing their first World Series title in franchise history, Milwaukee now has to figure out how to keep their roster competitive while several players from their Fall Classic roster enter the free agent market.

One of those players is right-handed starter Dustin May, who joined the Brewers just before the trade deadline last year and became an intriguing, albeit inconsistent option for their starting rotation down the stretch. Once the season officially came to a close, May decided to take his services elsewhere, agreeing to a three-year, $52.5 million contract with the Chicago White Sox earlier this week. His departure leaves Milwaukee with another role to consider as they begin to construct their pitching staff for the 2027 season.

The Brewers do have a number of young arms who could help fill the void left by May's departure. However, on the flip side, May’s experience and veteran presence will certainly not be easy to replace. Milwaukee is also waiting to see what happens with Brandon Woodruff -- another key veteran piece of the 2026 pitching staff who has since hit free agency. Meanwhile, Jake Bauers' effective denial of the Brewers' qualifying offer when he signed his four-year, $58 million deal with the Boston Red Sox has certainly freed up some money for Matt Arnold and the Brewers' front office, but how they choose to spend said money remains to be seen.

Dustin May’s departure leaves Brewers facing rotation decisions as offseason action picks up

May’s decision to sign with the White Sox means Milwaukee will have one less option as they construct their 2027 starting rotation. Fortunately for the Brewers, they have several young pitchers who are poised to step into larger roles next year. To no surprise, Jacob Misiorowski, Logan Henderson, Robert Gasser, and Kyle Harrison are among the internal options, while other names like Quinn Priester, Shane Drohan, Coleman Crow, and Brandon Sproat all offer intriguing upside as well.

There is certainly plenty of young talent within the organization to replace the departing arms, but relying on inexperienced pitchers to handle the better part of a full season undoubtedly comes with some risk. The Brewers defied the odds in 2026 by succeeding despite an inexperienced starting rotation. However, adding another experienced arm would inevitably give Milwaukee some stability while continuing to allow their younger pitchers to develop.

The Brewers could explore the free-agent market for another experienced starter, though a major investment feels unlikely. Nick Martinez, Michael Lorenzen, Cal Quantrill, and even former Brewer Colin Rea are a few names who could be worth considering. It's certainly worth remembering that the Brewers rostered Jake Woodford for the first two months of the 2026 season, proving a veteran innings eater is among the roles on their early-season pitching staff.

In the past, as many fans know, Milwaukee has found ways to fill the role without making the biggest splash in free agency (i.e. the Woodford deal), and this offseason could serve as another opportunity to follow that same approach. In fact, a reunion with Woodruff this offseason might be the perfect opportunity for the Brewers to add an under-the-radar veteran innings eater to their roster. A relief role for Woodruff, on the right deal, could be the best option for both the veteran right-hander and the Brewers.

Ultimately, the Brewers have built much of their success by developing young talent and finding value in places other teams might overlook. However, on several occasions, they've also elected to pair that pitching youth with a veteran arm or two who can guide the emerging arms through the early years of their careers. Maybe that veteran arm is Woodruff in a modified role, or maybe it's an external addition. How the Brewers round out their rotation this offseason could serve as a representation of whether the club wants to lean into its youth in the face of uncertainty, or stock up on veteran stopgaps with extra money to spend.

Add us as a preferred source on Google