The Milwaukee Brewers have never been an organization that likes to swim too deep into the free-agent waters, rarely extending themselves beyond some depth signings that always seem to work out and the occasional play for a high-upside guy who has yet to totally figure things out in the big leagues. That's especially going to be true this offseason, what with the impending lockout truncating everything and a freshly minted championship roster lacking any obvious holes.
That's not to say that the Crew won't have talent to replace -- Jake Bauers and Dustin May have already signed contracts that exceeded most of our expectations -- but they don't have the proper motivation to buck trends and sign a marquee free agent this winter. It's just the nature of the way this team does business.
So, when reading up on Mark Feinsand's ideal free-agent fit for every team, I wasn't expecting to see anyone of real note linked to the Brewers. Still... Austin Hedges? Really?
Brewers' ironclad catching plan leaves little room for further additions
I don't mean to deride Hedges or his ability as a player; the 34-year-old backstop has a tremendous defensive track record and just had the best offensive season of his career with the Cleveland Guardians. He deserves to get paid accordingly by a contender in need of some stability behind the plate.
That doesn't describe the Brewers, though. Feinsand does note that any interest in Hedges would be reliant on a William Contreras trade, which hasn't seemed very likely since the moment he won World Series MVP. But even if he does get moved, the fit with Hedges just isn't very clean.
At this point in his career, the veteran catcher is nothing more than a backup. Milwaukee already has a defensively-minded backstop in that position in Bo Naylor, Hedges' former teammate in Cleveland. Naylor's 2026 campaign was far worse, but he's also eight years younger and will be much cheaper while going through arbitration for the first time. It's not really economical for the Crew to bring in an older, more expensive player with a similar profile.
That also fails to mention the presence of top prospect Jeferson Quero, who is the heir apparent to Contreras behind the plate. He also didn't have a banner season this year, but he's only 24 and already on the 40-man roster -- the Brewers have to get him some playing time in 2027 to determine if he's ready to take over for the reigning World Series MVP, who is only under team control for one more season. Additionally, as of last night, fellow catching prospect Matthew Wood is now a member of the Brewers' 40-man roster, giving the reigning champs four backstops on their now-full 40-man.
Barring a series of trades or injuries, whatever money Hedges will command in free agency would probably be better spent on upgrading other areas of the roster, like first base or the bullpen.
