Brewers: 5 Bold Predictions For The 2024 Season

It's that time once again where we boldly predict what will happen in the upcoming Milwaukee Brewers season. A lot has changed from last year's team to this year's squad. While a lot of the changes may not seem as positive for this year's outlook, there's plenty of reasons to be optimistic.

Despite all the changes, the Brewers are still expected to compete for the NL Central division title and get back to the postseason where their luck may finally turn.

There's a new manager at the helm in Pat Murphy, Freddy Peralta has been promoted to staff ace, and 20 year old phenom Jackson Chourio has arrived.

That's all happened just over the offseason, what's going to happen during the season? Let's look at what we can see in our crystal ball in our 2024 Brewers bold predictions.

Bold Prediction #1: Rhys Hoskins leads NL in home runs, wins Comeback Player of the Year

One of the best moves the Brewers made this winter was the free agent addition of Rhys Hoskins. After cutting ties with Rowdy Tellez, trading Mark Canha, and letting Carlos Santana walk, the Brewers desperately needed yet another makeover at first base.

They decided to bring in longtime Phillies first baseman Rhys Hoskins on a two year, $34MM contract with an opt out after the 2024 season.

Hoskins was the top available first baseman on the market this winter and the Brewers were quick to strike to get their guy. He's coming off a torn ACL suffered in last year's spring training that kept him out for the entire 2023 season. It led to him being open to taking a modified pillow contract to reset his value and hit the open market coming off a platform season to earn a long term deal. That was the perfect situation for a small market team like the Brewers, who would be unlikely to be able to afford Hoskins on a long term contract.

After missing so much time, Hoskins is hungry to get out there again. He's hungry to prove he's deserving of the big money contract he wants. Plus, he gets a chance to prove it playing half of his games in a hitter's paradise at American Family Field.

In his career, Hoskins has never had a full season with fewer than 27 homers. The only exceptions were the shortened 2020 season where he had 10, and his rookie season where he slugged 18 long balls in 50 games.

He's also never led the league in homers. Until this year, I boldly predict. Hoskins will lead the National League in home runs. There's a lot of competition with Matt Olson, Pete Alonso, and now Shohei Ohtani in the National League, leading the NL will be a challenge, but it's certainly not impossible.

On top of the home run barrage Hoskins will have, he'll also collect a Comeback Player of the Year award for his triumphant return from missing the entire 2023 season due to his torn ACL.

A new Brewers season is nearly here, and you can boost your bankroll to bet on the fun with an instant bonus at DraftKings! Just sign up, deposit $10 or more and then bet $5 or more on any wager. You'll instantly win $150 in bonus bets! Sign up with DraftKings with this link today.

Bold Prediction #2: Trevor Megill steps up to be the closer in Devin Williams' absence

The Brewers will be without All Star closer Devin Williams for the first half of the season as he deals with stress fractures in his back. In his absence, the Brewers are left to figure out how to fill their closer position in the bullpen.

To begin the year, manager Pat Murphy will go with a rotation of relievers in the position. They'll mix and match and aren't going to commit to a certain player just yet. Time will tell who steps up in that role and several guys are in line to get a shot.

The favorite among many Brewers fans and pundits is Abner Uribe. He's been pegged as a future closer for a long time due to his blistering fastball, but control issues have plagued him.

I don't think it's going to be the favorite, this wouldn't be much of a bold prediction if I did. I think instead it's going to be a trade pickup from last year in Trevor Megill. The Brewers got him from the Twins for cash considerations and minor league pitcher Taylor Floyd, who was a PTBNL.

Megill also has a blazing fastball, put up good numbers last year with a 3.63 ERA in 31 games as a Brewer. He earned high leverage opportunities as the season went on and is heading into 2024 as a high leverage option once again and someone who will be a part of the group that will get 9th inning chances.

Joel Payamps may get the first shot, Abner Uribe will also get looks, but ultimately I think it's going to be Megill who steps forward and earns the job until Williams comes back.

Bold Prediction #3: Aaron Ashby and Robert Gasser become the top trusted starters behind Freddy Peralta

Is it possible the second and third best starters on this team won't even make the Opening Day rotation? It definitely is and this rotation is going to change a lot throughout the 2024 season.

The Brewers rotation went from a bona fide strength for the past couple of years to filled with a lot of question marks for 2024. Corbin Burnes is now in Baltimore, Brandon Woodruff is out for the year, while Adrian Houser and Eric Lauer are gone. After Freddy Peralta, there is not a lot of certainty in this group.

That leaves opportunities for young pitchers to take advantage of. The Brewers have already lost one veteran in Wade Miley to the IL to start the year and the veterans that are in the group aren't super inspiring with the combination of Jakob Junis, Colin Rea, and Joe Ross. Milwaukee has young pitching prospects ready for big league chances and a couple of them are due to step forward. Quite frankly, the Brewers will straight up need a couple of young pitchers to step forward.

The favorite among many to step up will be DL Hall. Hall is a young arm that came over in the Burnes trade, but his walk issues may not be fixed right away and he's never thrown 100 IP in a season before, which concerns me about his durability to remain a starter all season without an innings limit.

I think the pitchers that step up will be Aaron Ashby and Robert Gasser, neither of whom are making the Opening Day roster.

Ashby has had big league experience before, but he missed last season due to shoulder surgery. He's going to start the year in the minors to finish ramping back up, but he'll be called upon quickly once he's ready and an opportunity presents itself. Once he's back up, I don't foresee Ashby going back down or losing his rotation spot.

Gasser is major league ready, and Pat Murphy indicated we'll likely see Gasser get the call early on this season. Once he's up and gets a few starts under his belt, the Brewers are probably going to like what they see and may ultimately want to give him starts over someone like Joe Ross or Jakob Junis.

Those veterans serve an important purpose, but they don't have the upside that someone like Gasser has at this point. The Brewers want to see what their young guys have this year. Gasser and Ashby are the future in this rotation, Junis and Ross are not.

There is one trusted arm in this rotation right now and that's Freddy Peralta. Who Murphy ends up trusting behind him is up for grabs, but as the season goes on, I think the two guys who will earn that trust are Ashby and Gasser.

Bold Prediction #5: The Brewers eliminate the Cubs in the Wild Card round, finally ending their streak of first round playoff exits

Usually my 5th and final bold prediction is something involving the Brewers winning the World Series. But I'm tired of these first round exits and much like Jim Mora, "Playoffs? I just want to win a game". The Brewers are 1-9 in their last 10 playoff games and the manager of that playoff record, bolted 90 miles south in the hopes of an easier path to playoff victory.

Instead, I predict the Brewers will once again win the NL Central crown, but fall short of earning the bye past the Wild Card round. It'll be difficult enough to win the division again, they certainly aren't getting enough wins to top the winner of the NL East or West to get the bye. So they'll play in the best of 3 Wild Card series and I predict their opponent to be none other than the division rival Cubs.

Those games would be in Milwaukee, where the crowd you know will be fired up to play against the Cubs and their manager. Instead of falling short in the postseason like the Brewers have every year since 2018, manager Pat Murphy will lead the Crew to victory and eliminate the Cubs and his old boss. The Brewers will end their playoff series losing streak and from there, momentum will build potentially for an even deeper playoff run. We've seen it happen before with this playoff setup.

As much as I would love to predict a Brewers World Series, and hey, maybe this is the year, just getting a playoff series win would be a great success and feels bold enough already based on recent history. Getting that series win and eliminating the Cubs at the same time would be even sweeter.