Brewers: 7 Manager Candidates To Take Over Now That Craig Counsell Is Gone

Craig Counsell is gone. It's a shocking development that leaves the Brewers in search of a manager for the first time since they fired Ken Macha in 2010 and hired Ron Roenicke. When Roenicke was fired in 2015, Counsell was immediately installed as the permanent manager.

Now the Brewers are left with a vacancy in the manager's spot and they're a little late to the party in terms of interviewing candidates. Stephen Vogt has been hired by the Cleveland Guardians, Carlos Mendoza has been hired by the Mets, and Bob Melvin has gone to the Giants. All the other teams with vacancies are weeks into the interviewing process.

With Craig Counsell now out of the picture, who do the Brewers get to manage their team in 2024? Here are some of the candidates they could pursue, including both internal and external options.

Brewers manager candidate #1 - Bench coach Pat Murphy

Pat Murphy is arguably the top internal candidate for the job. He's been Counsell's right hand man since 2016, is well respected and loved in the Brewers clubhouse, and is deserving of an opportunity as a manager.

Everything you can do as a coach in the game of baseball, Murphy has done it. College coach, minor league manager, big league manager, big league bench coach, you name it. He's as experienced a baseball mind you could find and he's already in the organization. If the Brewers don't find an external candidate to their liking, promoting Murphy from bench coach to manager would be a logical direction.

Murphy may be the choice if the Brewers want to get a new manager named as quickly as possible. If they aren't too interested in looking externally, Murphy could soon be the name. If the process drags on, it could become less and less likely that Murph ends up with the job.

Brewers manager candidate #2 - First base coach Quentin Berry

If the Brewers want to go internal and prefer to go younger at the manager spot, Quentin Berry would be a possibility. He's been on the staff a few years, and again is beloved in the clubhouse.

Berry was an outfielder known for his speed. He was picked up by contending teams to be used as a pinch runner on their playoff rosters. The Brewers were one of those teams that picked him up and they brought him into the coaching ranks after he retired from playing. It's a similar career arc to Craig Counsell, ending his playing career in Milwaukee then staying in the organization in some capacity before being moved into the manager's spot, if Berry is indeed the choice.

Counsell was one of those players that was commonly thought of as a future manager and while there may not have been as many voices saying the same about Berry, that doesn't mean he wouldn't make for a quality manager.

Brewers manager candidate #3 - Former Cubs manager David Ross

This would essentially act as a trade. The Cubs took the Brewers manager and dumped David Ross for Counsell. Perhaps the Brewers could pick up Ross to fill their vacancy. It seems like a trade down for the Brewers, though. Ross wasn't the best manager down in Chicago, but it's not like he was a problem for them.

There were many reasons the Cubs fell short of their goals with Ross at the helm and while there were complaints about his managerial style, it's not like Brewers fans didn't have their complaints about Counsell either.

Ross is an unexpected name on the market now. The Cubs were totally content to keep him as their manager until they found Counsell to be available. He hasn't had any interviews with other teams and now that the Brewers have an opening, he could very well be one of the guys Milwaukee calls as their search ramps up.

Brewers manager candidate #4 - Rangers bench coach Jeff Banister

Jeff Banister should be a priority for a Brewers team looking to end their World Series drought. Banister is the bench coach for the Arizona Diamondbacks. He knows what it takes to coach a team successfully in October and get to the World Series, something the Brewers haven't been able to do. They've made the postseason but have been eliminated in the first round each of the past four times.

Banister has managerial experience as well, serving as the skipper for the Texas Rangers from 2015-18. He was then a special assistant in the Pirates front office before being hired by the Diamondbacks for their bench coach position ahead of the 2022 season.

During this managerial interview cycle, Banister has been a pretty hot name around the league. He was dealt a tough hand as manager of the Rangers back then and his performance as the bench coach for Arizona has been excellent.

Plucking a coach from a team that has had postseason success may be the best way for the Brewers to end their own postseason woes.

Brewers manager candidate #5 - Team USA manager Mark DeRosa

Former big leaguer and former Cub infielder Mark DeRosa has been a popular name in recent years as a potential future manager. Another smart, cerebral former player that doesn't have much experience in the job but makes sense to pick as a manager.

DeRosa has interviewed in the past for managerial jobs but his lack of experience was a sticking point. As a result, DeRosa was the manager for Team USA in the World Baseball Classic early this spring to get some experience under his belt. Team USA made it to the WBC finals, but ultimately fell to Team Japan.

I could see DeRosa getting an interview with Milwaukee. He's spoken highly of the team in the past and does so regularly as an analyst on MLB Network. With his experience managing Team USA, DeRosa will have something on his resume to prove he's ready to manage an MLB team.