Brewers Draft: Complete Draft grades for the Brewers 2024 Draft class

The 2024 MLB Draft has come and gone and the Milwaukee Brewers have made 22 selections. How did the Brewers do with all those picks?

Before we get into the grades, we need to remember a standard caveat here. We won't truly know how good these picks were for at least another 3-5 years. Drafts can look good on paper now, or even look terrible on paper now but that can all flip on its head as players develop.

These initial grades can serve to help us understand how the Brewers did in the Draft in the moment and can be looked back on as a check of just how right...or wrong the Draft experts were at the time. With all that said, let's get into the report card.

Round 1 - Braylon Payne, OF
Grade: C+

Braylon Payne was a surprise selection in the first round. Most prognosticators had Payne outside the Top 50 prospects in the Draft and the Brewers took him at 17 overall. The Brewers are going to save a bunch of money in their signing bonus pool with this pick as Payne's a well under-slot selection. That's a large reason why they took him here.

There's still a lot of good in Payne's profile. He's incredibly fast, and should end up as an elite glove in centerfield because of it. He'll steal a ton of bases and he's still just 17 years old, so there's a lot of room for projection and growth.

However, there are some drawbacks. The hit tool is very raw and may never be above-average, which it'll need to be in order to make full use of his speed on the bases. Power is presently not there, but perhaps could show up with added strength as he physically matures and gets stronger. The throwing arm also is not great, it should be good enough for centerfield, but is nothing special.

Payne described himself as a five tool player and perhaps he could be in time. In order for this grade to improve, he'll have to develop into that. Payne will most likely not be moving quickly through the minor leagues and so much is dependent on that bat developing. Yes, the Brewers were looking to save money here, but there were other options on the board where they could've saved money with a little less risk in the profile.

Day 2 picks

Round 3 - Jaron DeBerry, RHP
Grade: C

The third round is a little early for a senior sign. The Brewers are saving money here, and it could be a very significant amount on the $788k slot value. Where that money gets allocated remains to be seen, but DeBerry himself as a prospect has limited upside.

College seniors generally aren't "projection" type guys but DeBerry kind of is. He's still thin and has room to put on weight and his fastball sits in the low-90s. He'll likely need to add on weight to help him add velocity and the ability to start in the big leagues. Like the prep arms, DeBerry has really strong spin rates on his stuff, so perhaps the Brewers pitching lab can work with him, but in the end it's likely a reliever look here.

Round 4 -Marco Dinges, C
Grade: A-

Dinges was a very productive bat for Florida State this year, even though he wasn't much of a catcher. The bat-to-ball skills are very good and there's solid power here, too. If he can stick defensively behind the plate, that bat profiles very well as a starter at that position. If he has to move off it, possibly to first base, the bat isn't quite as good for those spots.

The Brewers have shown a knack at developing catchers defensively even if they don't currently have great defensive chops. Milwaukee believes Dinges has the tools to stick back there and they'll send him out behind the plate, but time will tell if he actually stays and makes it to the big leagues as a catcher.

The bat is what the Brewers are buying here and it's a very good one.

Round 5 - John Holobetz, RHP
Round 6 - Chandler Welch, RHP
Round 7 - Mason Molina, LHP
Round 8 - Sam Garcia, LHP
Grade: B

A pair of college righties and college lefties in the middle rounds give the Brewers a few more pitching lab projects while saving some money. Garcia is the only college senior of the group, so there may not be a ton of money savings here but there definitely will be some.

All of these guys will likely be sent out as starting pitchers but there is very real reliever risk with each one of them. Some might stick as a starter for a while, some might not. If any of them do stick as starters, it's back end of the rotation upside.

Molina was the highest ranked of this group but his struggles at Arkansas this season pushed his stock down.

Round 9 - Griffin Tobias, RHP
Round 10 - Ethan Dorchies, RHP
Grade: B+

The Brewers finished out Day 2 with a pair of projectable high school pitchers. Again, these are very risky arms but there is a lot of upside with these two.

Tobias and Dorchies don't presently throw as hard as Meccage and Levonas on Day 1, as these two sit in the upper 80s or low 90s, but they also have great feel to spin pitches. Projectability is the name of the game here and it'll take some time to develop these two, but they could turn into something special.

Milwaukee was saving money for most of Day 2, and these arms are where some of that money is going to be going, but there's also a lot that will go to Day 3 picks...

Day 3

Round 11 - Caedmon Parker, RHP
Round 12 - Tyson Hardin, RHP
Grade: A-

The Brewers start Day 3 with some guaranteed signs with college relievers. However, the Brewers will send both out as starting pitchers initially and there's reason to believe they could make that jump. Parker has big time stuff and a full arsenal while Hardin had a great season at Mississippi State.

It was a decade ago the Brewers took a Mississippi State reliever early on Day 3 and turned him into a starting pitcher. The Brandon Woodruff experiment turned out to be quite the success. Perhaps Hardin could follow in those footsteps. However, I'm not trying to put that expectation on Hardin to be that, but it is a possibility. These two won't cost the bonus pool anything and they could develop into big leaguers.

Round 13 - Joey Broughton, LHP
Round 14 - James Nunnallee, C
Grade: A+, if both signed

Now we get into the tough part of Day 3 and signability questions. If the Brewers are able to save enough money to sign both away from college commitments, this will be a huge coup on the third day and both prospects could soon enter the Brewers top 30 prospects list.

Let's start with Broughton. A lefty pitcher, Broughton has a big fastball that has great movement on it and a pair of breaking balls with big time spin rates. He's like the left-handed version of Meccage and Levonas, except perhaps a little more raw with the command. He had more of an early Day 2 grade but could have second round value. His stock fell a bit after an injury this spring and the Brewers nabbed him on Day 3 and if he signs, that's a big lefty pitching prospect to add.

James Nunnallee would be an equally huge signing. High school catchers are also notoriously risky and take a long time to develop. But Nunnallee was a second round talent by some prognosticators and he's committed to UVA. A left handed hitting catcher with great bat to ball skills and potentially some power to come could be the future behind the plate for Milwaukee. If they get him to sign, he likely becomes the Brewers top catching prospect behind Jeferson Quero.

Round 15 - Travis Smith, RHP
Grade: A

Smith is a pitcher who was ranked far higher than he went and as a college pitcher, his leverage is much lower than any of these high school picks. There may be some thought that Smith won't sign as he's committed to Mississippi State in the transfer portal, but while returning to school as a senior may get Smith a Day 2 pick next year, the money will likely be lower.

Smith has really good stuff, and is getting further away from Tommy John surgery. His ERA was bad, but the pitch data is good and he should get better results being beyond his first year back from surgery.

Round 16 - Jayden Dubanewicz, RHP
Round 17 - Cooper Malamazian, SS
Round 18 - Tyler Renz, RHP
Round 19 - Noah Wech, RHP
Round 20 - Henry Brummel, RHP

Grade:
If 3 of 5 sign, A+
If 2 of 5 sign, A-
If 1 of 5 sign, C
If 0 of 5 sign, D

Five more high school dart throws to finish out the Draft for the Brewers. They won't be able to sign all of them. Dubanewicz is committed to Florida, Malamazian and Brummel to Indiana, Wech to Oklahoma State, and Renz is committed to St. Johns. They will all be tough to get but the Brewers should have enough money left to convince some of them to sign.

Renz is the highest rated and is going to the lowest profile school, so getting him would be a big signing. Malamazian is an exciting player with speed to burn and a strong hit tool. If the Brewers can sign him, that's another exciting late addition like Josh Adamczewski last year. If I had to pick just two to sign from this group of five, those two would be my choices.

The four pitchers are all very similar profiles. They sit in the upper-80s or low-90s with their fastballs and have breaking pitches with high spin rates and very projectable body types to go with it.

Overall Draft
Grade: B+

Overall it was another solid Draft class for the Brewers front office. A lot will depend on how many of those Day 3 picks sign. Last year the Brewers got way more than most expected and Tod Johnson expects they'll sign a similar amount of Day 3 prepsters this year.

The top of this Draft class is different than last year's though. While Wilken was under-slot, he was a college performer that was expected to go first round, could move quickly, and has a very high floor. Payne was a surprise first rounder and the Brewers can only save 25% maximum on that slot value since he was a Combine attendee.

The risk with Payne is super high. There's a ton of risk in this Brewers Draft class in general, actually. There's a lot of pressure on the high school pitchers to carry this class, the riskiest basket you could possibly put your eggs in.

The most surefire big league contributor from this group might be Blake Burke. Even then, he's probably an average-ish defender at first base and likely a DH eventually.

With so many pitchers, even though the risk level is high on most of them, the Brewers pitching development staff is arguably the best in baseball and they should be able to develop at least one or two of these arms into major league contributors. If at least one of Meccage and Levonas, plus one more pitcher from the rest of this class turn into useful arms, this will go down as a very good Draft class.