Brewers Prospects: Grading the Debuts of the 2023 Draft Picks

Grading Debuts of 2023 Draft Picks

(1.18) 3B Brock Wilken: A+

As the Brewers' first-round pick out of Wake Forest, Brock Wilken did everything that you could hope for in his first minor league season. Wilken was drafted with the 18th pick in the draft after posting a .345/.506/.807 with 31 home runs in just 66 games, and he continued the success of this season into the Brewers' system.

He crushed his way through rookie ball, owning a 1.036 OPS in his seven games there, before spending a majority of his minor league season in High-A Wisconsin. In his 34 games with the Timber Rattlers, Brock Wilken reached base at a .427 clip (.865 OPS), splitting his time with 27 games at third base and 7 games at DH.

His season didn't stop there, as he would reach Double-A Biloxi for the final six games of the season and slash .217/.280/.565 with four extra-base hits. While the on-base numbers did dip a bit for Brock Wilken in his final stretch of games in Biloxi, even making it through three levels and into Double-A in his first season is nothing short of incredible.

(2.54) 3B Mike Boeve: B+

With Milwaukee's second-round selection, they opted to take another third baseman, this time selecting Mike Boeve out of Nebraska-Omaha after a crazy offensive season that concluded with a .512 OBP and a 39/29 BB/K ratio. Boeve came out of the gate scorching hot as he compiled 15 hits over 9 games for the ACL Brewers of the rookie league, posting.500 batting average and a 1.556 OPS in thirty at-bats with the club.

This start would lead to a promotion to High-A Wisconsin, where he would cool off a bit statistically (.250/.333/.333 in 19 games), but his overall season numbers would still be in a very good spot, ending his first season with a .329/.400/.529 slash in 28 games. Boeve should get his shot as the full-season starting third baseman for Wisconsin next year, and he will hope to sustain his early-season success there.

(3.87) 3B/SS Eric Bitonti: B-

The Brewers focused on some youth after selecting two college hitters with their first three selections, landing 17-year-old Eric Bitonti out of Aquinas High School (CA) with their fourth selection. Bitonti showed some flashes in his first short stint with the ACL Brewers, but he would also show some flashes of this youth.

In 48 plate appearances in rookie ball, Bitonti slashed .180/.333/.410 while walking nine times and striking out fifteen times. While his walk rate was very good at 18.8%, he struck out in 31.3% of his plate appearances, leaving some to be desired in that category. While his batting average was very low, he still held a decent OPS at .744, and four of his seven hits were for extra bases (2 HRS). As Bitonti is 2.8 (!) years younger than the average rookie league player, it is a very good start for him to get any at-bats at this age, and even though there was some struggle, there was a lot of good to pull from, as well.

(6.182) SS Cooper Pratt: A

Milwaukee took a huge swing in the 6th round of the draft by selecting the Mississippi-committed Cooper Pratt with the 182nd selection and won big by signing him to a contract with a bonus that was over a million dollars over slot value. Pratt was rated as the 45th best prospect on the entire board in the 2023 MLB Draft, and his talent showed up quickly with the ACL Brewers.

Pratt slashed .356/.426/.444 in 18 games, including a 3-hit debut and a 1.250 OPS against left-handed pitchers. Pratt saw time at shortstop, second base, and DH over his time in rookie ball, seeing half of his games at the shortstop position. The only real knock on Pratt was his lack of extra-base hits, with just two doubles and a triple in these contests, but the rest of the stats jump off the page for the 19-year-old prospect. Pratt had an excellent debut in 2023, and it will be interesting to see what Milwaukee's plan for him is in 2024.

(7.212) LHP Tate Kuehner: B

Tate Kuehner was the highest-selected Brewers pitcher to debut in 2023, being Milwaukee's 7th-round selection after a successful four-year career at Louisville. Kuehner straddled between starting and relieving for Louisville over three years, but settled in nicely as a bullpen arm in 2023, pitching to a 3.99 ERA in 38.1 innings while striking out 54.

Kuehner landed in the middle with the ACL Brewers in 2023, making a relief appearance in his first outing and starting his second outing. In three innings for the ACL Brewers, Kuehner didn't allow a run, struck out two, and walked one. Albeit a very small sample size, Kuehner had success in these innings and was able to get his feet wet in the minor league system before starting his first full season next year. At 22 years old already, the Brewers could opt to move Kuehner up the system quickly, and it remains to be seen if that will be as a reliever or a starter.

(8.242) RHP Craig Yoho: D+

After spending three years at the University of Houston as a position player, Craig Yoho transferred to Indiana and performed well as a reliever, earning him an 8th-round selection by Milwaukee. Yoho had a 3.41 ERA in 37.0 innings pitched at Indiana, excelling with his swing-and-miss stuff. He struck out 63 batters in these innings (36.2% of batters), and Milwaukee hoped this would carry into his first minor league season.

Yoho made three appearances with the ACL Brewers and allowed a run in all three. He would end his first season in affiliated ball with a 10.13 ERA in 2.2 innings pitched, allowing six hits and striking out three. While I struggle giving a grade this low to anybody for such a small sample size, Yoho did struggle, and especially at his advanced age of 23 in rookie ball (1.7 years older than the average player), it is a bit discouraging to see these results. Yoho will get a fresh start next year, entering his age 24 season, and will look to grow from the ups and downs of his first MiLB experience.

(10.302) RHP Morris Austin: C-

The Brewers shot for upside in the college ranks when they selected Houston Christian pitcher Morris Austin with their tenth-round selection. After struggling through his freshman year, Austin underwent Tommy John surgery in April of 2022 after posting a 1.08 ERA in eight appearances that year, and returned for the end of the 2023 season, allowing three earned runs in 3.2 innings. Milwaukee bet on the arm talent ofthe 23-year-old Austin, who touched 99 MPH on his fastball in summer outings with the Portland Pickles.

His debut with the ACL Brewers had some ups and downs, allowing earned runs in two of his four appearances, but striking out five in his 3.2 innings with the club. Austin sported a 7.36 ERA in his initial rookie ball action and walked four while only giving up two hits. Milwaukee will look to hone in Austin's command issues (7.9 BB/9 in college) and continue to work on turining his arm talent into production out of the pen in 2024.

(15.452) 2B/SS Josh Adamczewski: D+

After hitting .473 with a .632 on-base percentage with the Lake Central (IL) Indians in the 2023 spring season, Josh Adamczewski shot onto draft boards and landed with Milwaukee as the 452nd pick of the draft. The Brewers took Adamczewski away from his commitment to Ball State with a $252,500 signing bonus (about $100,000 over-slot), and he would make a very short debut with the ACL Brewers.

In eight plate appearances in rookie ball, Adamczewski would go 0-7 with one walk and three strikeouts. Again, I struggle to give him such a low grade given the sample size and his age, but he did seem to be a bit overmatched by the rookie league competition. Being 1.8 years younger than the average rookie league player, it is still great for Adamczewski to get any sort of experience before heading into his first full minor league season.

(16.482) RHP Josh Timmerman: C+

The lowest draft pick to debut in 2023 for the Milwaukee Brewers was Josh Timmerman, a reliever-starter hybrid who spent two years at Wabash Valley Community College before finishing his senior season at Ohio State University. While Timmerman with command and had a high ERA (8.37), his strikeout numbers were very good, fanning 13.7 batters per nine innings in his 23.2 innings pitched last season. Timmerman also posted a 1.72 ERA in 15.2 innings for the Brewster Whitecaps of the Cape Cod Baseball League this summer.

Timmerman made two appearances (one start) for the ACL Brewers in the 2023 season and allowed two runs in three innings pitched while striking out one batter in each appearance. Timmerman is still relatively young at 20 for a college arm, so Milwaukee will be cautious with his development over the next few seasons.

It speaks quite highly to the quality of the Brewers' draft class that so many draftees were able to debut this season and even move past the rookie league in some cases. Fans should be excited about how some of these players might end up looking once 2024 rolls around.