Milwaukee Brewers: Grading the Crew's Starting Pitchers in the 2023 Season

In the world of Milwaukee Brewers baseball, one thing you can always count on is solid starting pitching. As we reflect on another season, it's time to dive into the performances of each regular starting pitcher.

While there were a few players who made spot starts, our focus here is solely on the consistent contributors who held down the fort throughout the season. Join me as we assess and grade the efforts of these key players who played a crucial role in the Brewers' success on the field.

Before we jump into the grading process, let me take a moment to outline my approach. I evaluate players based on a combination of their performance and the expectations set for them. This dual perspective is crucial to avoid unfair comparisons, such as grading an ace and a backend starter on the same scale.

It wouldn't be equitable to give a lower grade to a fifth starter simply because they didn't meet the standards of an ace. Therefore, considering our expectations for each player is a key factor in the grading criteria. It ensures a fair and contextual assessment that takes into account the unique roles and responsibilities of each player on the field.

RHP Corbin Burnes: B

Despite turning in a formidable effort with a 3.39 ERA (3.81 FIP), a 1.069 WHIP, and just shy of 200 innings pitched, Corbin Burnes' 2023 performance wasn't quite the encore Brewers fans were expecting. Sure, he earned his spot in the All-Star game, but his ERA took a noticeable uptick from his Cy Young campaign in 2021, where he boasted a career-best 2.43 ERA, followed by a 2.94 ERA in 2022.

Burnes showcased more inconsistency on the mound this time around, resulting in a mediocre 18-14 record for the Brewers in his 32 starts—an unexpected outcome when your ace is on the hill. One could try to argue that run support played a part in that, however Milwaukee average a solid 4.68 runs per game in his starts, so that's not exactly the case. Add to that the offseason contract disputes that rubbed some fans the wrong way, and whispers of trading Burnes began to circulate.

However, even though Burnes' 2023 season may have fallen short of the sky-high expectations, it still qualifies as an above-average performance. Considering the high bar he set in previous years, I'd say Burnes deserves a B for his efforts.

RHP Brandon Woodruff: A-

Brandon Woodruff's season was a rollercoaster of challenges, primarily due to injuries limiting him to just 11 starts. However, in those limited appearances, he showcased nothing short of brilliance. Woodruff posted a stellar 2.28 ERA (3.60 FIP) and an impressive 0.821 WHIP. What stands out even more is his remarkable consistency—allowing two runs or fewer in nine out of his 11 starts, never letting the opposing team score more than four runs.

Despite Woodruff's reliability and stellar performance on the mound, the Brewers finished 7-4 in his starts. However, before we point fingers at Woodruff, it's worth noting that the team's lack of run support played a significant role. In his losing starts, Milwaukee averaged a mere two runs per game.

Now, the grading dilemma arises. While it's unfair to penalize Woodruff for factors beyond his control, the reality is that he only made 11 starts. Despite A+ level performance in those outings, it's a challenge to hand out the highest grade for such a limited sample size.

RHP Freddy Peralta: B

Next is Freddy Peralta's performance on the mound during the past season. The stat sheet shows a 3.86 ERA (3.85 FIP) and a 1.117 WHIP, which, at first glance, appear quite commendable, especially given his career-high 30 starts. However, Peralta's season wasn't a smooth, uninterrupted ride; it had its fair share of peaks and valleys.

At certain points, Peralta saw his ERA climb as high as 4.73, revealing the rollercoaster nature of his performance throughout the 2023 campaign. This inconsistency reflected in the win column, with the Brewers going 17-13 in games started by Peralta.

Unlike Woodruff, where losses could be attributed to a lack of run support, Peralta's situation was more varied, with his performance impacting the outcomes of most games, barring a few exceptions. Milwaukee averaged 4.82 runs in Freddy Peralta starts. 

While Peralta did ultimately deliver a solid season for Milwaukee, the unpredictability of his outings created a bit of a rollercoaster ride for fans. The final numbers may have met expectations, but the journey to get there leaves a lingering sense of disappointment. In the grand scheme, Peralta's season deserves a respectable grade, but the ups and downs make it challenging to hand out top honors.

LHP Eric Lauer: F

Eric Lauer's season unfolded as a tale of profound disappointment. Coming into the year as a presumed fixture in the backend rotation, Lauer swiftly lost that role. In 2022, he had showcased promise with a 3.69 ERA in 29 starts, complete with a standout early-season performance that had fans buzzing. Despite a second-half cool-off, Lauer was respected as a reliable backend starter.

However, 2023 told a drastically different story. Lauer's contribution to the Brewers dwindled to just 10 appearances (9 starts), and the numbers were grim—a 6.56 ERA (7.41 FIP) and a 1.671 WHIP. His struggles prompted a stint on the IL, and he spent the majority of the season in Triple-A, where his performance further faltered, registering a 5.04 ERA in 13 appearances (10 starts).

This was far from meeting even the modest expectations set for a backend starter. In fact, recent news about the Brewers placing Lauer on waivers, followed by his outright assignment to Triple-A, serves as a stark exclamation point on this dismal performance.

LHP Wade Miley: A

Now, let's turn our attention to the next southpaw in the rotation, Wade Miley. His return to the Brewers had fans buzzing with excitement, despite some reservations about the 36-year-old's health. However, Miley, the crafty veteran, proved that age was just a number as he consistently delivered outs. Despite a couple of brief stints on the IL, Miley showcased his durability with 23 starts and an impressive 3.14 ERA (4.69 FIP), along with a 1.139 WHIP.

Miley was slotted in as the expected stellar fifth starter for the Brewers, and he not only met but exceeded those expectations. By the end of the season Miley was no longer considered a backend starter due to his performance. Honestly, there are no complaints to be had, and no substantial points to dock.

RHP Colin Rea: B+

Colin Rea entered this season with modest expectations, perhaps anticipating the chance for a lone spot start if luck favored him. However, with the starting rotation nursing injuries, Rea found himself appearing in 26 games, making 22 starts. Over this stretch, he posted a 4.55 ERA (4.90 FIP) and a 1.187 WHIP.

Manager Craig Counsell often limited Rea's outings to prevent facing the batting order three times, but regardless, Rea consistently gave the Brewers a fighting chance to win. The team boasted a 15-11 record in games where Rea took the mound. While not every performance was flawless, Rea's ability to keep the Brewers in the game earned him more starts as the season progressed.

In essence, Rea's contributions became a lifeline for the team amid the challenges posed by injuries to key starters. Without his steady performances, Milwaukee might have found themselves on the outside looking in when it came to the playoffs. Overall, it was a solid season for Rea, showcasing his reliability and impact in critical moments.

RHP Julio Teheran: B

Julio Teheran, brought in by the Brewers as a midseason addition to bolster the pitching staff amidst injuries, proved to be a shrewd signing. Over the course of the season, Teheran made 14 appearances, including 11 starts, posting a 4.40 ERA (4.93 FIP), and a solid 1.130 WHIP.

Teheran's arrival in a Brewers uniform saw a blazing start with his first six outings. However, the journey became a bit more uneven as the season progressed. Milwaukee ended with a 5-9 record in games where Teheran took the mound.

While the overall season performance may be described as pedestrian, Teheran's noteworthy six-start run was for the Brewers. His contributions were instrumental in filling innings during a challenging period for the team, and he managed to do a respectable job overall.