Milwaukee Brewers: Greatest Catchers In Franchise History

Last month the Milwaukee Brewers made a trade for catcher William Contreras, acquiring him from the Atlanta Braves, marking arguably the highest optimism the Brewers have had since Omar Narvaez was named an All-Star in 2021.

Prior to that the Brewers had Yasmani Grandal for one season in 2019 perform well, 2.4 WAR behind the plate. In 2017, Manny Pina had his best season as a Milwaukee Brewer, posting a 2.6 WAR. The Milwaukee Brewers have had four different starting backstops in the past six years.

The Brewers are hoping to get some consistency for the future of the position with William Contreras, but let's look at the best catchers from the past.

Greatest catchers in Milwaukee Brewers history: Honorable mention

There have been some absolutely great seasons at catcher from players donning Milwaukee Brewers uniforms over the years, albeit in short stints that make them hard to declare them the top players the Brewers have had behind the plate. One being the aforementioned Yasmani Grandal who spent just one season in Milwaukee. A season that helped drive up his free agency value. In 2019 with the Brewers Grandal hit 28 home runs, the most by a catcher in Brewers history.

Jim Sundberg is another one year wonder for the Milwaukee Brewers, similarly to Grandal he played just one season in Milwaukee but was selected as an All-Star in 1984. Sundberg slashed .261/.332/.399 and had an OPS of .731.

The Pineapple, Manny Pina deserves a nod as he spent six season with the Brewers and while none of them leapt off the page, Pina was a consistent, dependable and likeable player by both fans and teammates and adopted himself to whatever role was required of him, whether as a starter or as a backup.

Going back to the Milwaukee Brewers in the infancy of their franchise the Brewers got a few solid seasons from Ellie Rodriguez. In three seasons from 1971-1973 Rodriguez batted .255, got on base at a solid .357 clip but sported a low .306 slugging percentage, indicative of the times as in the 1970s baseball was more about getting on base than hitting for power. That didn't stop Rodriguez from making the 1972 All-Star game however. In 1972 Rodriguez had the third highest WAR season a Brewers backstop has ever had at 3.8, behind two players who will appear on this list later. Rodriguez slashed .285/.382/.352 for a .734 OPS that year. The 123 OPS+ Ellie Rodriguez posted would be the highest of his career.

Darrell Porter would be the Milwaukee Brewers next starting catcher following Rodriguez's three seasons with the team. Darrell Porter spent the first six seasons of his 17 year MLB career as a member of the Milwaukee Brewers. In that time Porter finished third in Rookie of the Year voting in 1973 and was a one time All-Star the following year in 1974.

Looking at his numbers, Porter certainly could have been an All-Star in 1973 as well when he had one of the best single seasons by a Brewers catcher. In 1973, his rookie season in which he played 117 games, Darrell Porter hit 16 home runs, drove in 67 runs and slashed .254/.363/.457, good for an OPS of .820 and a WAR of 3.6, according to baseball-reference. Porter did have a 3.7 WAR in 1975. Those two seasons mark the fourth and fifth highest wins above replacement for a Brewers catcher in franchise history.

Charlie Moore was the next Milwaukee Brewers starting catcher after the departure of Darrell Porter to the Kansas City Royals. Moore played nearly his entire career as a Milwaukee Brewer, he spent 14 of his 15 MLB seasons in Milwaukee. Moore slashed .261/.319/.355 in his time wearing a Brewers jersey from 1973-1986. Moore lands as an honorable mention due not to his overwhelming power, he hit just 36 home runs in 14 years, but due to his longevity as a member of the Crew.

Last but certainly not least, a guy who was hard to leave out of the top three, BJ Surhoff. Surhoff played nine years as a Milwaukee Brewer, the longest tenure of any Brewers backstop. Despite not having any All-Star appearances, Surhoff did have a fantastic 1995 season when he slashed .320/.378/.492 for an OPS of .870, although that season was great, Surhoff only played 18 games at catcher in 1995. What impresses me most about Surhoff's tenure with the Brewers is that he never struck out more than 49 times in an entire season as a member of the Brewers.

Greatest catchers in Milwaukee Brewers history #2: Ted Simmons

Ted Simmons was the starting catcher of the legendary 1982 season that is still talked about to this day. Ted Simmons became part of the Milwaukee Brewers in "the trade that made Milwaukee famous". Simmons came to Milwaukee alongside Pete Vuckovich and Rollie Fingers in December of 1980, the rest as they say, is history.

Before the Milwaukee Brewers acquired him, Ted Simmons had already been an All-Star six times and a perennial MVP candidate. Simmons made two more All-Star appearances in his five years with the Brewers from 1981-1985 in 1981 and 1983 respectively.

Ted Simmons' 1983 season was nothing short of fantastic, the second best in Milwaukee Brewers history by WAR, according to baseball-reference. In 1983, Ted Simmons slashed .308/.351/.448 for a .799 OPS. Simmons hit 13 home runs and drove in 108 runs, the most by a Milwaukee Brewers backstop in a single season.

In his five years as a Brewer, Simmons slashed .262/.311/.399, numbers not as good as they were while he was a member of the St. Louis Cardinals but still enough when paired with the seasons that were among some of the best in franchise history, land him at number two of the Milwaukee Brewers all-time catchers. To Simmons' credit, like Surhoff, Simmons struck out extremely rarely, never more than 51 times in a season as a member of the Brewers.

In 2020, Simmons was finally elected to the Baseball Hall Of Fame on a veterans committee ballot. His Hall of Fame case never got a real chance on the writers ballots but an injustice was finally righted with his election a few years ago.

Greatest catchers in Milwaukee Brewers history #1: Jonathon Lucroy

Recency bias be damned, Jonathon Lucroy is the best catcher in Milwaukee Brewers history. Never mind the fact that he played seven seasons with the Brewers, second only on this list to BJ Surhoff, but Lucroy could probably be considered the best in franchise history off his 2014 season alone.

In 2014, Jonathon Lucroy broke Ivan "Pudge" Rodriguez's record for doubles by a catcher in a season with 49, when he hit 53 doubles. Not only did that break the single season record for a catcher, but he also led all of Major League Baseball in doubles in 2014. Lucroy slashed .301/.373/.465 for an .837 OPS, his 131 OPS+ that season is the second best in franchise history. Lucroy was named an NL All-Star and broke up what could have been a run of seven consecutive All-Star games for Buster Posey who is likely a first ballot Hall of Fame catcher. That 2014 season, Jonathon Lucroy posted a 6.4 WAR, the highest by a catcher in Brewers history. Lucroy finished fourth in MVP voting.

Jonathon Lucroy was an All-Star again in 2016 but was traded to the Texas Rangers in a deal that netted the Brewers Lewis Brinson, who would later become the centerpiece in the Brewers trade for Christian Yelich.

Over his seven years with the Milwaukee Brewers Jonathon Lucroy batted .284, got on base at a .342 rate and slugged .436, combining for a .779 OPS and 110 OPS+. In his seven seasons Lucroy hit 79 home runs and 157 doubles, those numbers aided him in driving in 387 runs in his tenure.

Lucroy never posted a fielding percentage below 98.8 percent as a Brewer and caught 176 runners stealing as a Brewers backstop. Lucroy took it personally that scouts didn't think he was a defensively capable catcher and worked tirelessly to improve that aspect of his game and it paid off. To this day, in the history of the Milwaukee Brewers, Jonathon Lucroy stands above the rest as the best catcher in Brewers franchise history.