With money to spend and a thin market of free agents who, for the most part, don't fit their recent roster construction strategy, the Milwaukee Brewers may look to execute an internal contract extension or two this offseason. Popular candidates for such deals are World Series MVP William Contreras and budding superstar Brice Turang, who finished third in NL MVP voting this year.
However, if a Contreras or Turang extension proves to be too expensive or if the Brewers want to extend another player alongside one of their two top-of-the-lineup staples, a long-term deal for one of their young arms could make sense. Jacob Misiorowski has likely priced himself out of the Brewers' budget with his Cy Young Award, which is okay -- the Brewers still have the flame-throwing ace under team control for the next five seasons. One or two of Miz's rotation colleagues, however, could emerge as an extension candidate during this accelerated offseason.
Thanks to the Detroit Tigers' recent extension of 25-year-old starter Troy Melton, the Brewers now have a solid reference point should they find themselves interested in extending one of their starting pitchers. Melton, signed a six-year, $46.5 million, with a $23 million club option, and the first season and a half of his major league career look very similar to the first season and a half of Logan Henderson's career. Therefore, should the Brewers engage in extension talks with Henderson this offseason, Melton's contract will almost certainly be cited as a reference point. Let's take a closer look at what that could mean for Henderson and the Brewers.
Brewers' hypothetical contract extension offer to Logan Henderson could mirror Troy Melton's deal with Tigers
Melton debuted halfway through the 2025 campaign and covered 45.2 innings while maintaining a 2.76 ERA in his rookie season. Henderson debuted during the 2025 season as well and covered 25.1 innings with a 1.78 ERA in the limited sample size. Both young right-handers returned with higher innings counts in 2026, but neither's effectiveness waned. Melton, amazingly, once again posted a 2.76 ERA, this time in 114.1 innings while Henderson turned in a stellar 2.47 ERA in 98.1 innings before serving as the Brewers' No. 2 starter in the postseason.
Both young righties, each of whom was drafted in the fourth round, have had very similar starts to their careers and therefore, are likely to command similar contract extensions. ESPN's Jeff Passan detailed the breakdown of Melton's deal, which looks something like this:
Troy Melton's six-year, $46.5 million contract extension:
2027: $1 million
2028: $1 million
2029: $4.5 million
2030: $7.5 million
2031: $11 million
2032: $18 million
2033: $23 million (club option w/ $1.5 million buyout)
*Escalators of up to $6 million included in contract
The Tigers bought out at least one free agent year with their six-year deal, and potentially two if the club option is exercised. They're assuming Melton, when he otherwise would have hit the free agent market after the 2031 season, would have commanded a salary worth more than $18 million on the open market and then more than $23 million for the 2033 season. It's a bet that the Brewers should make with Henderson as well.
Henderson is at the exact same point of his career as Melton, with two more seasons of pre-arbitration, league-minimum salaries still ahead of him before he hits arbitration eligibility in 2029. Three seasons of arbitration eligibility currently has the 24-year-old Henderson under team control through the 2031 season -- his age-29 season. However, if the Brewers offer Henderson a similar extension to the one Melton just signed, he could be under contract through his age-31 season, which coincidentally is a time the organization has far less guaranteed money already on their books.
A contract extension like the one Melton just signed makes plenty of sense for Henderson right now, but the Brewers also have another underrated extension candidate among their rotation options: Kyle Harrison. That might sound like a ridiculous idea given the way Harrison finished the 2026 season and the fact that he didn't make a single postseason appearance despite being rostered in every series, but if the Brewers trust his first-half breakout, that second-half slump simply lowers the price of a contract extension Milwaukee should want to sign.
If Harrison can replicate the success he had during the first half of the 2026 season -- 3.01 ERA, 29.6% strikeout rate, 5.9% walk rate, 1.08 WHIP -- which presumably he should be able to, seeing as his downturn in production aligned perfectly with a stint on the IL, indicating it was more injury-related than anything else, he's absolutely someone the Brewers should consider extending this offseason.
Harrison is one year ahead of Henderson in the arbitration process, meaning he would otherwise be a free agent after the 2030 season, but a six-year contract, which would buy out two free agent years rather than one, might still look rather similar in price given how Harrison's stock dropped in the final weeks of the 2026 season. If the Brewers trust the breakout, having the 25-year-old Harrison under team control for an additional two seasons or three with a club option, could pay dividends down the road.
The Brewers have executed similar deals in the past with both Freddy Peralta and Aaron Ashby. Peralta's five-year, $15.5 million deal, which came just before the world shut down in 2020, effectively bought out two free agent years, but the Brewers had the flexibility of club options for both seasons. Ashby's $20.5 million deal also buys out two free agent years with club options. Whether it's five years with two club options or six with just one, the youth of both Henderson and Harrison makes the pair intriguing contract extension candidates. With Melton's deal as a reference point, the Brewers have a place to start negotiations with either of their young starters.
