The Milwaukee Brewers typically aren't big players on the free agent market, but this offseason there should be a little extra money to spend. Not only are the Brewers fresh off a World Series run that provided additional financial resources, but also, unlike 2026, they won't have anyone playing on the expensive qualifying offer in 2027.
It remains to be seen how the Brewers will make use of this extra payroll space, but in addition to an internal contract extension or two, the idea of upgrading their bullpen via the free agent market has been floated. Milwaukee has already bolstered their relief depth by trading for San Francisco Giants' right-hander Ryan Walker, but an additional upgrade, especially if they elect to trade Trevor Megill, may be required.
Many fans are hoping for a reunion with southpaw JoJo Romero, who ended up being a key part of the Brewers' World Series run. Other folks are hoping for a bounce-back candidate like Pete Fairbanks or even Kenley Jansen at the end of his career. One option that is now off the table is electric right-hander Jonathan Loáisiga, who we at Reviewing the Brew cited as a potential fit for the Brewers earlier this week. On Friday morning, however, Loáisiga agreed to a contract with the New York Yankees and in doing so, set a high price for reliever upgrades on the free agent market.
Yankees, RHP Jonathan Loáisiga reportedly agree to a 2-year deal with a 3rd year option, per multiple reports including @MLBNetwork insider @JoelSherman1. pic.twitter.com/aDpfTnQvuY
— MLB (@MLB) November 20, 2026
Brewers' free agent target Jonathan Loáisiga signs two-year, $18 million deal with New York Yankees
Loáisiga was by no means a perfect fit for the Brewers, but there's no denying his upside. An injury-riddled career that began with the Yankees way back in 2018 moved to Arizona in 2026, where Loáisiga, finally healthy for a full season, posted a 2.42 ERA in 67 innings with dominant underlying metrics. Though his strikeout rate didn't jump off the page, Loáisiga was elite at inducing weak contact and groundballs while averaging nearly 98 mph on his fastball.
"Buying high" on a player after his best season is not something the Brewers typically do (see Jake Bauers), but Loáisiga wasn't expected to command a huge free agent contract due to his injury history. Early offseason projections had the 32-year-old reliever earning $6-7 million per season over the next two years. That's a number the Brewers typically wouldn't pay for a reliever, but could certainly afford if Loáisiga continued to produce the way he did during the 2026 campaign.
However, the Yankees, who initially signed Loáisiga to their organization back in 2016, were willing to increase the price tag to make sure the potentially dominant right-hander returned to the Bronx. Worth a guaranteed $18 million, Loáisiga's agreed-upon contract doesn't just take another option off the board for the Brewers, who are presumably at least checking in on the free agent relief pitcher market, but it also sets a high bar on the market should Milwaukee ultimately elect to pay for a bullpen upgrade.
From Loáisiga's two-year, $18 million deal to Evan Phillips' three-year, $35 million deal with the Atlanta Braves, it's clear that pitching won't come cheap on this thin free agent market. As a result, unless the Brewers want to use a majority of their additional payroll this year on one arm, it's likely Milwaukee's bullpen reinforcements won't come from the top tier of free agent relievers. Maybe the Brewers will be able to scoop someone up on a one-year deal if they fall through the cracks, but Milwaukee's front office isn't typically in the business of paying top dollar for relief pitcher upgrades.
The Brewers certainly have money to spend and a need for bullpen help that will only be heightened by a Megill trade. However, Milwaukee has built a perennial contender in the smallest market in baseball by getting the most out of their payroll, and meeting the high prices of the top tier relief pitcher market doesn't seem to fit that strategy.
