Brewers: 2022 Season Report Card Grades For The Outfield

1 of 3

2022 was a year filled with many ups and downs for the Brewers outfield group.

Prior to the season starting, David Stearns pulled off a last second trade with the Boston Red Sox on the eve of the lockout starting. This deal got the Brewers off the hook of a bad Jackie Bradley Jr contract of which he severely under-performed during his one season with the Crew. It also brought in Hunter Renfroe, who at the time had two years of club control remaining.

The Brewers’ big free agent signing over the offseason was Andrew McCutchen. While he did serve primarily as the designated hitter, his alternative position was in the outfield. Due to this, he will factor into the outfield season report card.

Returning in the outfield to begin the 2022 season was Christian Yelich, Tyrone Taylor, and Lorenzo Cain. Unfortunately Lorenzo Cain did not finish the year playing baseball as he was designated for assignment on the day he reached 10 years of MLB service time. He was scuffling at the plate through 43 games played and because of his early departure from the club he will not receive a 2022 report card grade.

As the 2022 season rolled along, we did get to see a few new faces in the outfield. Jonathan Davis was brought up to play center field following the departure of Cain. We also got to see two outfield prospects debut. Garrett Mitchell saw the most substantial amount of playing time as he spent the final month of the season in the big leagues. Esteury Ruiz, who was acquired in the Josh Hader trade, made just three appearances, so he will not factor into this year’s outfield grade.

In this article, we will give a report card grade on each of these Brewers outfielders’ seasons.

1) Garrett Mitchell 2022 Season Grade: B+

Mitchell’s MLB career got off to a rip-roaring start. He collected two RBIs with his first major league hit on August 28. A day later, he hit his first career home run that came in the late innings and sparked a come from behind victory against the Pirates.

Following that home run, he struggled mightily over his next 25 at-bats in which he collected just two hits and struck out 13 times. Then, from September 16 to the end of the season he slashed .469/.500/.625/1.125 over 35 at bats. This impressive stretch of games began on the day he collected his first career walk-off hit that occurred against the Yankees.

Overall, Mitchell finished the year with a .311 batting average, an .832 OPS, a 41% strikeout rate, and eight stolen bases. For a prospect to be thrust into the mist of a playoff race, he performed quite well.

He was not allowed any time to settle in as every at-bat and defensive play was being watched very closely and had playoff implications. There are areas that he can improve upon next season, such as the strikeout rate, but his speed should continue to make him an asset on the basepaths and in the outfield.

MILWAUKEE, WISCONSIN – AUGUST 29: Christian Yelich #22 of the Milwaukee Brewers walks to the dugout during a game against the Pittsburgh Pirates at American Family Field on August 29, 2022 in Milwaukee, Wisconsin. (Photo by Stacy Revere/Getty Images) /

Christian Yelich 2022 Season Grade: D+

2022 was another year of Yelich not rebounding and returning to or near MVP form.

During our 2021 season report card, we highlighted Yelich’s lack of quality contact (exit velocity) on ground balls that led to a perception that he was hitting more ground balls than normal. In 2022, his ground ball rate actually rose to 59% (55% in 2021) and he overall made slightly better contact, but still not great contact.

In regards to standard statistics, Yelich saw subtle changes when compared to last season. His .252 batting average was just four points better than 2021, his on base percentage decreased by seven points to .355, slugging percentage was ten points higher at .383, and his OPS had just a two point difference (.738 vs .736).

There are some positives from Yelich’s 2022 season. One being that he stayed healthy and avoided an injured list stint. The back issue that seemed to plague him in 2021 was a non-issue this year.

Another positive is that he settled into the role as leadoff hitter. At the leadoff spot he slashed .267/.378/.390. Continuing to have him serve in this role may be the best way to maximize his current skill set going forward.

Given that there was no substantial change in his performance when compared to last year, he received the same letter grade as last season.

Tyrone Taylor 2022 Season Grade: C-

After forcing himself into the outfield rotation in 2021 due to good performance, Tyrone Taylor got a long look at every day playing time in 2022 following the departure of Lorenzo Cain. Overall, Taylor appeared in 120 games and put together a slash line of .233/.286/.442 with a .728 OPS.

The most alarming offensive statistic is Taylor’s .286 on-base percentage. In 2022 his walk rate decreased to 5.4%. This is a 2% drop compared to last season. Things get more discouraging when you combine his low on-base percentage with his rather non-impressive .233 batting average.

Yes, Taylor did a good job at hitting for extra bases in 2022, as he hit 17 home runs, 21 doubles, and three triples. But moving forward there may be other players that will have more to offer offensively. This may push Taylor back into more of a backup outfielder role.

ST. LOUIS, MO – AUGUST 13: Hunter Renfroe #12 of the Milwaukee Brewers hits an RBI triple during the tenth inning against the St. Louis Cardinals at Busch Stadium on August 13, 2022 in St. Louis, Missouri. (Photo by Scott Kane/Getty Images) /

Hunter Renfroe 2022 Season Grade: A-

Hunter Renfroe performed to expectations in 2022. As a former member of the Red Sox and Padres, he is known for hitting near 30 home runs and having perhaps the best throwing arm among outfielders. During his first year with the Brewers, he slugged 29 home runs and collected 11 outfield assists.

Production wise, Renfroe finished first among qualified hitters on the Brewers in regards to batting average, slugging percentage, and OPS. Overall, he was third on the team in regards to home runs and RBI (72). He was fourth in hits (121) and fifth in doubles (23) as well. A hamstring injury early in the season did slow him down for a bit, otherwise he may have put up even better numbers.

Andrew McCutchen 2022 Season Grade: D

A big point of emphasis for the Brewers heading into 2022 was getting more right-handed batters that can hit against left-handed pitchers. Career wise, McCutchen has dominated in those match ups. In 2022, he was less than impressive and hit just .221/.303/.435/.738 against lefties.

Overall, McCutchen’s offensive performance was underwhelming. He was signed to be the team’s designated hitter, which he was, but unfortunately his big offensive production days are behind him. It would not be surprising if the Brewers let him walk this offseason.

Jonathan Davis 2022 Season Grade: C-

Davis was brought up to the big leagues to provide depth following the departure of Lorenzo Cain. Overall, he appeared in 37 games for the Crew before being placed on the IL with an elbow injury and eventually outrighted to the minor leagues. At season’s end, he did elect free agency.

On the offensive side, Davis did perform well below the league average to the tune of a 77 wRC+, but he did have some defensive gems. His most memorable catch came against the Tampa Bay Rays when he put his body on the line as he dove head first into the center field wall. He landed extremely awkwardly, briefly remained in the game, and was eventually removed.

As a depth piece signed to a minor league deal the offseason prior, Davis didn’t bring much to the table offensively but was a pleasant surprise defensively. Because of this he gets a slightly below average letter grade for his 2022 season efforts.

Next. Brewers Face A Difficult Decision With Keston Hiura. dark

As a unit, the Brewers outfield group again did not meet expectations in 2022. With Christian Yelich’s salary increasing and Hunter Renfroe being one of the most expensive arbitration eligible players on the team, offensive production has to be better in 2023 from the outfield group.

Home / Brewers News

Brewers: 2022 Report Card Grades For The Outfield