Brewers outfielder has come back to earth after unsustainable start to the season

Garrett Mitchell has been walking a tightrope all season, balancing big strikeout rates and a patient approach with huge exit velocities and lots of walks. It worked for a bit, as Mitchell hit .273/.437/.436 through his first 20 games in 2026.

Unfortunately, his production has died out since then, with a .424 OPS in the following 15 games marking a full-fledged cold snap. The last week and change, in particular, has been brutal, as the center fielder is hitting just .129/.176/.161 since the start of May.

Unsurprisingly, strikeouts are once again the primary culprit for his recent downfall. He's punching out at a 41.2% rate in May, with only two walks in 34 plate appearances to show for it. Even as he continues to produce elite exit velocities, his power numbers simply won't creep up to respectable levels (hence why his OBP has outpaced his slugging percentage in recent weeks).

His value to the Milwaukee Brewers is obvious -- both in and out of the batter's box -- but Mitchell's frustrating inconsistencies have reached an apex this season.

Garrett Mitchell has the potential be elite, but the Brewers are once again having to exercise patience for him

The good news is that Mitchell has stayed healthy to this point. He's played in 35 of the team's first 38 contests, which seemed like a prerequisite for those hoping for a breakout from the former first-round pick.

Unfortunately, he remains disastrously bad at putting the bat on the ball, with an eye-popping 37.5% whiff rate that ranks as the sixth-worst figure in the sport this year among all qualified hitters. No matter how many walks you draw or how hard you hit it when you do make contact, very few ballplayers are equipped to succeed when they're swinging and missing with that kind of frequency.

It just so happens that it's possible that Mitchell is one of those lucky few. He's one of the fastest players in baseball, and no matter what Defensive Runs Saved has to say about it (he's at -3 this year), he's also one of the league's premier center field gloves with a cannon for an arm. In effect, he's a legitimate four-tool player when factoring in the dormant power his exit velocities suggest he's got hiding somewhere.

It's a darn shame that the one lingering tool -- his hit tool -- is lagging so far behind. He's tried to compensate for it this year by swinging at a career-low rate (he offers on just 40.5% of all pitches), but that also means he's watching more strikes pass him by than ever before.

The 2026 season has been a microcosm of Mitchell's career to this point. He's got all the telltale signs of a superstar, but he just isn't making enough contact to play at that level consistently. At least with better health, the Brewers will get more chances to evaluate which version of Mitchell they think they'll get moving forward.

Add us as a preferred source on Google

Follow