Brewers’ uncertainty at shortstop is a blessing, not a cause for concern

With just over two weeks remaining in spring training, anticipation and anxiety are mounting over the Milwaukee Brewers' Opening Day lineup. While fans and analysts can reasonably predict the starting rotation and much of the infield configuration, one major question looms: Who will replace Willy Adames at shortstop? Manager Pat Murphy has yet to provide any clarity, recently stating that he "couldn’t put a deadline" on naming the Brewers' next starting shortstop.

Despite the uncertainty, the competition for shortstop remains a race where both options present strong cases. Last season’s Platinum Glove-winning second baseman, Brice Turang, is a safe and reliable choice known for his defensive excellence. The other, Joey Ortiz, who played third base last year, has displayed impressive versatility across the infield.

Turang appears to be the logical selection based on his elite fielding, but there’s an argument against disrupting what has worked so well. Instead of focusing on who takes over at shortstop, the Brewers must also determine who will replace the player shifting to short.

Infield adjustments set off a chain reaction

If Ortiz moves to shortstop, the hot corner would most certainly become a platoon featuring lefty Oliver Dunn and right-handed rookie Caleb Durbin. Additionally, utility player Andruw Monasterio remains an option to contribute as well. Dunn has enjoyed a slightly stronger spring training performance, though the difference among the candidates doesn't jump off the page.

Alternatively, if Turang transitions to shortstop, it could pave the way for spring training standout Vinny Capra to secure a spot on the Opening Day roster. Capra made a statement early in camp with a pair of three-run homers and has maintained an impressive batting average above .300. He’s also showcasing some speed on the base paths and making a compelling argument for a spot.

However, the Brewers’ front office must weigh this decision carefully, as Capra is out of minor-league options. If they commit to him, they must be confident he’s ready to thrive under the pressure that comes with being an everyday big leaguer. While Capra isn't a lock at second base, his versatility, along with Monasterio’s, makes him a valuable asset who could provide depth wherever needed.

The task of replacing Adames is daunting. We're talking about some who finished 2024 with 32 home runs, 112 RBIs, and 118 OPS+. Something that can't easily be replicated. However, Milwaukee has an exciting mix of talent eager for an opportunity. The Brewers’ shortstop situation may not have a clear answer yet, but the competition and depth in camp suggest that the team is in a strong position moving forward.

The uncertainty may be unsettling for fans, but the upside is undeniable. The Brewers have a unique opportunity to allow emerging players to prove themselves, potentially setting the stage for a new core in the infield. With Opening Day fast approaching, all eyes remain on Murphy and his final decision. Regardless of the outcome, there’s reason for optimism in Milwaukee.

More Brewers News from Reviewing the Brew