In Major League Baseball, where established players are routinely traded for prospects, it can often take years for the true winner of a deal to be crowned. Milwaukee Brewers fans know this better than most.
Take, for example, the once-infamous Josh Hader trade. Milwaukee looked like the obvious loser of the trade at the time after a post-trade collapse that saw them go from first in the NL Central to missing the playoffs. Short-term fill-in Taylor Rogers struggled in a Brewers uniform, Dinelson Lamet never made the team, and fans rightfully questioned why a first-place team would trade their All-Star closer in the middle of the season. However, now, four years later, the deal looks much better, seeing as it netted the Brewers southpaw Robert Gasser, who emerged as a key part of the team's memorable title run, and led to the front office acquiring William Contreras, who was named the World Series MVP this year.
Though it took a few years, Brewers fans now look back on the Hader deal with mixed feelings rather than straight-up disdain. Certainly, the World Series title helps, but the fact that Gasser and Contreras were integral to said title makes it even better. It's an important reminder that the type of trades the Brewers have relied on in recent years, trades that send All-Stars elsewhere in exchange for prospects, are supposed to take time to succeed. Many of these trades are long-term moves in which the winner cannot be determined for many, many years.
There exist, however, instances where the Brewers have been the ones dealing prospects for short-term help. The moves that Milwaukee made at this year's trade deadline certainly fall into that category, but so too does an offseason deal the Brewers swung back on January 2, 2025. In exchange for left-handed pitching prospect Mason Molina, whom Milwaukee drafted in the 7th round of the 2024 MLB Draft, the Brewers acquired right-handed reliever Grant Anderson from the Texas Rangers. Fast forward less than two years, and Molina is turning heads in the minor leagues, but not in the Rangers' system.
Former Brewers prospect Mason Molina, who was traded for Grant Anderson, named St. Louis Cardinals' Minor League Pitcher of the Year
Molina logged just two appearances in the Brewers' farm system before he was dealt to the Rangers, where he lasted only a little bit longer. Halfway through the 2025 season, Molina was traded again, this time to the St. Louis Cardinals in a deadline deal that sent reliever Phil Maton to Texas. In the time since, Molina has established himself as one of the most exciting arms in the Cardinals' farm system. In fact, on Thursday morning, Molina has been named St. Louis' 2026 Minor League Pitcher of the Year.
Congratulations to Mason Molina on being named our Minor League Pitcher of the Year!
— St. Louis Cardinals (@Cardinals) November 19, 2026
Between Double-A and Triple-A, Molina made 27 starts and struck out 150 batters in 123.2 innings pitched. pic.twitter.com/XI5gdlZBG3
It's a well-deserved honor for Molina, who posted a 2.87 ERA in 14 Double-A starts this year before earning a promotion to Triple-A. Molina's numbers took a slight hit at the top level of the minor leagues, where he posted a 4.45 ERA in 13 starts, but the overall body of work was certainly impressive for the 23-year-old southpaw. His 28.5% strikeout rate and 86.4 mph average opponent exit velocity were especially strong.
With Molina impressing on the doorstep of the big leagues, the conversation regarding the Brewers' 2025 trade with the Rangers has certainly shifted. Prior to Molina's breakout, the talk of the trade was the fact that the Brewers turned Anderson, who sported an 8.10 ERA in his final season with the Rangers, into a legitimate bullpen weapon. Over the last two seasons, Anderson has posted a 3.29 ERA while averaging nearly 60 appearances per season.
Anderson's been a quiet, but important piece of the Brewers' bullpen over the last two seasons and remains under team control through the 2029 season. He has experienced the career turnaround the Brewers were anticipating when they traded for him two years ago, and figures to be a necessary part of Milwaukee's 'pen once more in 2027. However, despite Anderson's impressive two campaigns in a Brewers uniform, it's hard to argue with the value of a high-upside, left-handed starting pitcher at the beginning of his career, and that's exactly what Molina is.
It took a few years and another trade for the outcome of the Anderson-Molina swap to gain clarity, but a trade that once appeared to favor the Brewers, now unfortunately favors their division rival. The Rangers could have been the real winners of the 2025 swap, but their decision to flip Molina at the following deadline is one they now wish they could take back. Though the Brewers are certainly happy to have landed Anderson two offseasons ago, they are now undoubtedly wishing they had traded a different prospect to acquire him.
