Logan Henderson validates Brewers' trade deadline decision in dominant victory over Tarik Skubal, Dodgers

Just two weeks ago, the baseball world was grappling with the fact that the reigning back-to-back AL Cy Young Award winner had been traded to the reigning back-to-back World Series champions. After a late-night blockbuster trade, many baseball fans woke up to the news that Tarik Skubal was officially a Los Angeles Dodger on Sunday, August 2.

Thus began a series of reports regarding what the Dodgers' competitors, including the Milwaukee Brewers, offered the Detroit Tigers for their left-handed ace, and whether or not another team could have topped the offer that was ultimately accepted. The general consensus among these varying reports was that the Brewers were willing to part ways with a number of top prospects, including No. 2-ranked prospect Luis Peña, in order to land Skubal, but where their offer fell short was their willingness to provide a controllable MLB-ready starting pitcher that matched the value of River Ryan, who was included in the Dodgers' accepted offer.

To beat the value of Ryan, whose polarizing profile has become a hot topic of debate since the deadline, many have speculated that the Brewers would have had to include rookie right-hander Logan Henderson in their offer to the Tigers. Those less familiar with Henderson and the Brewers' method of operation were shocked to learn that Milwaukee wasn't willing to part ways with the 24-year-old right-hander to pair Skubal with NL Cy Young frontrunner Jacob Misiorowski and form one of the most daunting starting pitcher duos in MLB history.

However, in the time since the trade deadline, Henderson, who thanked Matt Arnold for not trading him away and has repeatedly noted how much he loves pitching for the Brewers, has validated the front office's decision to treat him as untouchable. Henderson added an exclamation point to that validation by outdueling Skubal himself in the Brewers' series finale against the Dodgers on Sunday afternoon.

Logan Henderson proves front office right for treating him as untouchable in Tarik Skubal trade deadline pursuit

Though many were hoping for a Misiorowski-Skubal duel in Los Angeles this weekend, the Brewers' front office, wanting the baseball world to see why they treated Henderson as untouchable at the trade deadline, were happy to see Skubal and Henderson line up for a matchup in the series finale. Skubal vs. the pitcher that the Brewers were unwilling to part ways with to acquire him was the perfect opportunity for Henderson to prove his front office right, and the young righty certainly delivered.

Henderson turned in the longest start of his career, covering seven innings against the Dodgers on Sunday afternoon. The rookie starter allowed just one earned run, a solo homer from Andy Pages, and three total hits while striking out six. Meanwhile, Skubal certainly pitched well himself, but not quite as well as the rookie Henderson. The Dodgers' trade deadline prize covered six innings, allowed two runs (one earned), and seven total hits. Skubal threw a career-high 109 pitches after the Brewers constantly put traffic on the bases and worked deep counts against the 2x Cy Young Award winner.

However, Henderson's outperformance of Skubal is not just limited to Sunday's series finale in Los Angeles. Each starter has turned in three starts since the Brewers elected not to trade one for the other at the deadline, and Henderson's numbers in those three outings certainly outweigh the performance that Skubal has turned in. Check out their stats since the trade deadline.

Stats since 2026 trade deadline:

Logan Henderson: 2-1, 19.1 IP, 2.79 ERA, 0.78 WHIP, 21 K, 3 BB

Tarik Skubal: 1-2, 17.0 IP, 3.18 ERA, 1.24 WHIP, 19 K, 6 BB

Yes, it's a small sample size, but that's kind of the point. The Brewers, had they acquired Skubal, only would have received 9 or 10 starts from the expensive trade deadline target during the regular season, and in a sample size that small, it's entirely possible for Henderson to outperform him. However, the Brewers wouldn't have been trading half a season of Henderson starts for half a season of Skubal starts; they would have been trading five and a half seasons of Henderson and a top prospect or two for half a season of Skubal.

There are still six weeks of the regular season remaining, and certainly a dominant performance from Skubal in the postseason could quickly change the narrative, but two weeks removed from the deadline, the Brewers' front office has absolutely been proven right for treating Henderson as "untouchable" at the trade deadline.

Add us as a preferred source on Google

Follow